The Top 100 Pound for Pound All-Time Greats

Well, are we not debating who belongs in the very top few tiers ghee Sauk sub!!54@!\>!

 

Yeah getting to two hundred would be excellent Mandell gets his name in the top 110 hopefully and I would like to think Brian Mitchell gets a mention

 

Walker, Ross above McFarland, Leonard.

 

Yeah.

Who would you rank higher, Joe Gans or Joe Louis?

 

Fair and understandable.

 

Without too much thought, I'd go with Joe Louis, close though. With Louis you just gotta throw him in somewhere. The closer you look, the worse he gets for me.

At least compared to these other mammoths.

 

Nah. Ranks high for dominance and gets big kudos for his ability. A lock for 11-15 for me.

I have Gans in the same bracket.

I just have not read enough on Packey. I know where he probably should be but I haven't got a good grasp on him yet and from what I remember he looked horrid against Welsh.

 

Ezz remains locked in above Fitz, aye?

 

Good. Good.


#4.

 

Armstrong has to be above Charles.

Question is should he be above Robinson as well?

 

The men bolded are really LHW's. I still think Louis is greater than Gans but this is what I mean by the closer you look the worse his résumé gets.

And is Braddock really that great? To be in with those names? That's why it's called the Hall of Fame.

 

Bivins was not 'really a LHW'! Not at that stage, although his best heavyweight form was gone already.

And just because they are in the HOF doesn't mean they're his best wins either.

Does that mean Jimmy Ellis wasn't a good win for Ali because he was really a middleweight? What about Floyd Patterson?