The winner of Calzaghe Hopkins is P4P1

:yep

 

Why cause you say so? :nut

 

if its a convincing win then the winner should definetely be number one.

 

u crazyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy no wayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy if anything neither should because calzaghe said he'll retire if he loses and hopkins ain't no spring chicken now is he win or lose hopkins won't fight again , there be no point giving either of these two the number 1 spot

 

so you rather have a guy at number one who instead of fighting the top contenders in his division he rather engage in freak shows like the WWE and fights part time fighters like DLH.

 

We need a blowout to get a #1 p4p from this fight, same case as in Pacquiao vs. Marquez. But the spot is definetly up for grabs because of Floyd's lack of desire to fight the best in his division. A division which is stacked right now which is even more frustrating.

 

ok point made

 

I definately agree on floyd. he doesn't fight so isn't (and doesn't deserve to be) #1 anymore imo.

I think it's very reasanable if the winner of tonight is #1

 

what about if margarito does fight cotto and beats cotto then somehow gets a match with floyd and beats him then he should be number 1

 

In short...

No.

 

Not on any CREDIBLE p4p list.

 

Pac is the active p4p

PBF should be, he is "retired" in an active sense.