The winner of Williams/Martinez should be the pound for Pound #1.

Lay of the crack dude! Seriously.
"what have they done for me lately?"

What do u want theM to do for u? suck ur dick?

 

i thought this was going to be a fail, but you present a lot of quality information :good

 

to play devil's advocate here...who, other than mayweather, is "above" pac's level in your opinion?

 

aaaaahhahahahha

 

I like how Maragrito is a "Beneath his level"...
Yet, Tony went tooth & nail with one of the fighter's you mentioned & beat the other's ass.
(Some Bum)

 

RESUME:

PBF notable wins against:
BALDOMIR
GATTI
CORRALES
DELA HOYA
HATTON
JMM
MOSLEY

PAC notable wins against:
MAB
MORALES
JMM
HATTON
DIAZ
DELA HOYA
COTTO
CLOTTEY


Now who has the better resume?

 

i agree for the most part a fighter is as good as their last fight, it's not a sure formula, but I do go by that as well. Martinez vs. Williams isn't getting the attention Pacman and Floyd are getting, but hopefully that will change in the future for either of these 2. I disagree with you sayin Pac hasn't fought the level of fighters Floyd has, clearly, Clottey is not on Mosley's level, it would be a competitive fight if those 2 did fight, but c'mon, the most boring fighter in the world Mora gave Mosley hell and in your own words, "A fighter is as good as his last fight", then my friend you know Mosley who struggled with an avg Mora was the same Mosley that almost ko'd Floyd. Mosley gassed out on Mora, further indicating he did gas out with Floyd for *****s that think he didn't.

Cotto, on the other hand, even though he struggled with Clottey, is on a higher level than Mosley and like Floyd, also beat Mosley. And to give Cotto more credit, Mosley was not gassing out on Cotto in their fight. That IMO was Mosley closer to his better days, but still past his prime. Just because Mosley steamrolled Margarito doesn't mean Floyd would do the same. You should know better having the most skill is a powerful weapon, but sometimes it's not enough to win them all. Floyd should school Manny, yet why didn't he school Castillo in their first fight? Sorry, but even though to be fair I do have Floyd as the #1 p4p for beating Mosley, because Mosley was the p4p#1 WW, Manny is easily as good as Floyd. At least I agree with you Manny is the #2, but no way has he fought lower quality than Floyd has. Not with that win over Cotto he hasn't. I don't care how crude, slow, off balance, and amateurish Margarito might seem, he always brings a constant danger and pressure to anyone he faces, even when he's losing. It's not as big as a win over Mosley, but it's not a walk in the park for any elite fighter whether it would be Manny or Floyd fighting Margarito.

 

What do wins from years ago have to do with current p4p rankings? Mayweather shouldn't even be on the list as he's on vacation.

 

Not a chance..

 

I actually agree. The winner of this fight should be #1. Considering that Pacman is fighting Margarito who isn't even on the P4P list and Mayweather isn't fighting anybody at all.

 

nope.....it should be number 4 tho...# 3 should belong to montiel imo!....:bbb

 

should be a number 3, but there are other factors. like rafa vs juanma the winner of that will shoot up the list. montiel vs donaire likewise.

 

pacquiao giving that he beats margorito should be number one. Martinez and williams still have alot left to do in order to be P4P 1

 

Martinez n PW are on the same level as margarito.

You have PAC/mayweather

Then:

Cotto, Mosley, pw, Martinez,

Then:

Clottey, cintron etc.