The worst scoring or decision in boxing history.

pacquiao-bradley 1

 

Some absolutely ridiculous choices here. We're talking worst decisions ever and there are some really close fights being named.

Holyfield-Lewis 1 and Escalera-Everett were awful decisions. The fights were not even close. The ****** and the tranny lover won easily.

Coggi-Gonzalez 1 is the most outrageous robbery, although it had nothing to do with the scorecards.

 

am i the only one that thought cintron martinez was disgraceful ?

the ref saw the punch which put him down and he did not make the 10.. THEN COMPLAINS OF A HEADBUTT the ref insisted "i did not see no headbut" and the replays confirmed it was a CLEAN punch and martinez's head was miles away from even coming close to cintron

martinez is celebrating a win and the ref allows himself to be persuaded... martinez gets robbed of a win and the fight is somehow called a draw?

also pwill v lara was ****ing disgraceful... one of those fights where im trying to play devils advocate to see if i can through some way give pwill the fight and there was just no way..

 

i agree.. alot of people naming mayweather or pac "robberies" when they were all close competitive fights

(i feel the third marquez pac fight was a robbery but i only gave it to marquez by 4 rounds so i suppose its still kind of competitive)

 

Campillo vs Shumenov off the top of my head

 

This... Reminds me of when my boy Paul Williams won a card against Sergio by the same margin in their razor close war. I though Williams won by 1 point. And tough to argue much wider than that.

This... Shockingly though, the Compubox stats closely resemble that of Mayweather/Maidana yet you have trolls saying Maidana won more than 4 rounds and choosing to reward volume at random times.

How ridiculous.

Mayweather vs. Castillo I was a close fight.

Mayweather vs. Oscar, Cotto, and Maidana were 117-111 type of fights... in favor of the man who properly won.

Talk about trolling, this guy...

I agree with this to the maximum. The worst decision ever.

I scored it 12-0 Chisora and I thought each round was decisive.

Boom. Great call...

Honestly, there are much worse cases out there... although it sounds weird because that fight was a true robbery. I do think Williams nabbed or was competitive in a couple rounds and there have been fights where one fighter wasn't even competitive in rounds and won.

I'm willing to go out and say it. In regards to their oft mentioned rematch, I scored it 117-112, or 8-3-1 Campillo. Not quite the absolute shutout some insinuate. Shumenov won a couple of those early rounds for sure before he gassed in round 4 and lost almost every single 30 second span of the fight after.


-----------------

People are naming too many fights here where the "winning" fighter actually won a good 3 or more rounds.

There have been decisions where the "winner" deserved to have lost every or all but 1 round.... like:


Brandon Rios vs. Richard Abril... arguable shutout win for Abril.

 

Campillo vs Cloud was a good Don King's performance too :rofl

 

i still dont have a clue wtf happened in Lara/Williams or Pac/Bradley

 

I was watching a recording of Michael Moorer vs Melvin Foster only the other day, and in it the commentators discuss the "myopic" judging that allowed Foreman to get the nod over Shulz.

The commentators went on to mention a poll someone conducted on the controversial result and just about everyone who voted felt Shulz was robbed.

 

easily jones vs that Korean guy.

 

This thread shows the posters who DKSAB

 

Pacquiao vs Bradley 1 .

Martinez vs. Cintron

Matthysse vs. Alexander (Alexander himself knows he lost that fight )

judge Gustavo Padilla of Panama scoring Hopkins vs Shumenov 114-113 for Shumenov - HORRIBLE

 

Ottke Vs Reid. Just for the hilarity of the ref warning Reid for punching Ottke in the head. Something I'll probably and hopefully never see in a boxing ring again. It really was beyond a joke.

 

Rios-Abril. Plus the one judge who scored Hopkins-Shumenov in favor of Shumenov

 

Thought Dirrell-Froch was pretty bad.

About half of Ottkes wins...