I like both guys (no secret, it's a PHILLY THING!), and this would be a very close fight either way! I would lean towards a Spoon narrow decision and would slightly root or pull for Young...but would not pick Spoon with any conviction nor be disappointed with any outcome!
I wouldn't go along with the school of thought here that thinks that Young outclasses Witherspoon. At his best, Tim wasn't really a fighter you could dismiss so casually. But I would still pick a peak JY against a peak TW by hard fought decision.