TIME TO VOTE: Who Should be Inducted to the Classic Hall of Legends This Year: 105-135LBS (CLOSED!)

Pedroza getting so many votes has got me puzzled. I'm not sure he would end up in my top 5 out of these guys. Like he has more votes than Attell, does the forum rank Pedroza higher than Attell at feather?

I'll vote for

Pete Herman
Abe Attell.

 

It hurt not to vote for Chang but he doesn't deserve it more than those two.

 

I for one do think Pedroza was a better fighter, from what I can see..... my personal criteria values how good the guy really was.
I think it has more to do with Attell being from such a long time ago though, it was such a different time.... Didn't Attell win one title fight because the police stopped it ? Wasn't he deeply involved with mobsters ?

Anyway, he is making it, surely, he got a lot of votes.

 

Herman and Rose. I was going to vote for Attell but outright motherf*cking refuse to see Rose with only one vote to his name.

 

Pedroza getting so many votes is making my teeth itch.

 

Chang and Pedroza.

 

I voted Attell and Pedroza.

Really it was Attell and one other. Attell is my #4 at FW. If he doesn't get inducted, then I will assume (**boxing history snob statement warning**) it will have been because not enough posters voting are familiar with the length and volume of defenses of his world title reign, or won't vote for fighters they've seen no film of.

Pedroza is WAY behind Attell at FW (the top 6 of Pep, Saddler, Saldivar, Attell, Sanchez and Dixon are way ahead), but still high at #7 for me. Rose is my #7 at BW and I may as well tossed a coin between him, Pedroza and Chang (Herman has an argument too, but lost far too many in and around his prime years for my liking). Pedroza just edged it for me, but I'd be equally as happy if Chang or Rose get it.

It really is Attell and one other, imo.

 

Abe Attell
Joe Brown

 

Lionel Rose
Jung Koo Chang

Chang gang runs these cold forum streets…

 

Lionel Rose
Joe Brown

Can't be too orthodox!

 

Abe Attell
Joe Brown
for me, but I really hate to leave the others like Galaxy or Kingpetch off.

 

Aba Atell and Jung Koo Chang.

 

Abe Attell
Pete Herman

 

Don't you mean making your nuts hurt à la Juan Laporte when he fought Pedroza?