James Toney could beat Haye if he were in shape. If he's able to beat guys at 257lbs he can beat Haye. His main battle is staying in shape. Wtf is he eating? Does he not train for months at a time? James Toney seems to have decent stamina, but he needs to lose the weight to get back his speed advantage which is what he'd need to beat Haye. I think Haye is overrated and can be beaten.
If that fat out of shape Chris Areola can get in the ring and fight for a title why can't James Toney?
The Toney that fought Holyfield, yeah, ok but this Toney is never beating Haye no matter what he weighs. He's done as a top-level fighter and, at this point, Haye would beat him easily.