Who would win? I feel in this instance,Tucker wins. Mike is too easy to hit here and will eat uppercuts all day every day. He also only threw one punch at a time pretty much.
The best version of Tucker vs the Tyson that lost to Douglas? I agree that Tucker has an excellent chance of winning.
If this is a question of whether Tucker who actually fought Tyson would beat Tyson who fought Douglas - IMHO Tucker would win.
Tyson would win. Tucker was just coming back after two years of inactivity in which he abused cocaine.