Modern era only(Mid 60s - present) 1.Roy Jones 2.Sugar Ray Leonard 3.Ricardo Lopez 4.Aaron Pryor 5.Manny Pacquiao 6.Roman Gonzalez 7.George Foreman 8.Wilfredo Gomez 9.Mike Tyson 10.Naseem Hamed
Pacquaio Gomez McClellan Julian Jackson Nigel Benn Jeff Fenech Carlos Zarate Danny Lopez Mike Tyson Jung Koo Chang But that is really just off the top of my head...nothing I feel strong enough about to debate
1 Roberto Duran 2 Joe 3 Bazooka Limon 4. Wilfredo Gomez 5 Foreman 6. Tyson 7. Fletcher 8. Pipino 9 Cyclone 10 Art Hafey
11 Hamsho 12 Yuh 13 Leon 14 BOZA 15 Saad 16 Nunez 17 Ganigan 18 Durelle 19 Shavers 20 Roldan 21 Olivarez 22 Chavez 23 oJuam Meza 24 McGuigan 25 Gati Gatti gatti 26 Hearns 27 Marvin Kohnson
Hamed was exposed by MAB and Jones was mainly a counter puncher, he sometimes had trouble opening lower level fighters up compared to the way the rest of the fighters on your list did, I feel Benitez fought better defensively v Leonard than Toney did v Jones and RAy landed far more punches on the extra slippery Wilfredo.
I feel Loma has more offensive skills than most boxers that have ever laced them up, he`s constantly jabbing and changing angles.
Roberto Duran Alexis Arguello Ray Leonard Wilfredo Gomez Mike Tyson Thomas Hearns Marvin Hagler Evander Holyfield Matthew Saad Muhammad Aaron Pryor Hector Camacho prior to Edwin
1.Roberto Duran 2.Jose Napoles 3.Ruben Olivares 4.Fighting Harada / Eder Jofre 5.Jung Koo Chang 6.Wilfredo Gomez 7.Julio Cesar Chavez 8.Roman Gonzales 9.Tyson / Holyfield 10.Alexis Arguello I'm probably forgetting people, but my first 4/5 would be set in stone from your time specified and onwards. Edit. Edited list slightly.
I am confused by this post you say "'Benitez fought better defensively v Leonard than Toney did v Jones'" yet Leonard should be ranked ahead? That makes no sense. Also probably Roy's #1 feat of his career is opening up and stopping guys who were PROVEN to have elite durability: Malinga Tate Thornton Hill Woods Sosa Literally no one is able to open you up like Roy could.