Top 10 P4P hitters?

3 154 pounders who are on the list mugabi, jackson and hearns

 

McClellan who banged out a couple of much smaller, past prime and not durable straight on fighters? Shockingly overrated as a fighter and as a banger IMO, though he was clearly a big puncher.

 

That's my thinking. Aesthetically I can see; he could hit.

But would he have been a massive hitter at 175?

For me his scalps do not prove him as a great P4P puncher. I'd rate Avelar over him as a pure hitter, no doubt.

I also assume you mean Lew Jenkins? If so, his reputation would lend credibility to him being just that.

 

you could make a fine list with these names (though as flea pointed out, you probably meant jenkins)

baer is a great puncher but a TAD overrated at times.

i would consider saddler (still need to learn more about his opposition though), and satterfield to

 

I'll roll with

Jackson
Langford
Hearns
Louis
Foster
Fitzsimmons
Tyson
Avelar
Olivares
Fitzsimmons
Tyson

In no particular order.

McGrain are you not including Louis because he was more an all-round puncher rather than a pure hitter? Because if so, 'Bazooka' Gomez fits into the same category.

As it stands, both worthy inclusions IMO.

 

:think not familiar with this gentleman

 

Banged people out, savagely, from fly to super bantam. A huge monster of a fly but he iced Vasquez @122, which wasn't impossible but proved he wasn't Jay a G-Man esque bully (same day weigh in's as well)

Watch his bouts with Shoji Oguma, Tae-Shik Kim and Wilfredo Vasquez, all on YouTube. Also, check out his K.O of some guy called Rocky Mijares, lesser level but destructive nonetheless.

He's my representative for the midgets, simply because there is no footage of Wilde stopping anyone :good

 

That was what I assumed, just something I'd heard before (kinda' similar to how Archie Moore sometimes gets left out of 'pure power' discussions)

****!!! I forgot Arguello, he's in my top 5 :deal

 

****! We all forgot Alexis atsch

 

:-( Obviously something in the air for no one to mention him.

Would he make your top 5?