top 10 p4p of all time

I am no Aussie expert (nor expert at much else either), but your list does not look that bad to me...there will always be a subjective element to any list and again our biases of eras, talent evealuation, modern vs classic and even the way we process information leaves a great deal of variety.

Again not an area I have exhaustivelly studied, but I tried to put a similar list together about a year or 2 ago:

1. Les Darcy
2. Young Griffo
3. Dave Sands
4. Jeff Fenech
5. Lionel Rose
6. Peter Jackson
7. Kostya Tszyu
8. Johnny Famechon
9. Jimmy Carruthers
10. ???????????

 

It was a joke.
I'm English. Some of the first waves of Aussies were British convicts ...