Would he have to be ? Does everyone who disagrees with verdict of a fight you watch have to be a liar? I know its a word you freely use about posters from the safety of your computer. Klompton also thinks Layne deserved the win over Charles,I've never read a report that agrees with him,that doesn't mean he is lying ,he is entitled to his opinion,as were the reporters who sat ringside and watched the fight live. I know when I went to the fights monthly I would record them and watch them later at home,and I often got a different slant on things.