Top 100 ATG - (My Personal List)

All I can do is laugh at you.

 

Good list i like it.:good


I wont tell you who i think is too high or too low because I'm in the middle of redoing my own list and the undertaking is immense.


Did my Original list over Christmas and it took Day's, but i now have about another 20 fighter's to evaluate and I'm struggling.

 

You have him about 33...about where most people have him from my experience and I dont reckon even his most ardent fans would have him that much in front of that.

 

Well the IBRO have his at 15 All time and i think that is too high, He is somewhat Overrated but i have him at 28.


Like i said i was happy with my First list but now have a lot more boxer's to evaluate that i missed first time so i got a lot of work to do this week.


I have to go but I'll post my Provisional list later and the other fighter's i am looking at that i missed first time.

 

I would like to see Ken Buchanan in there somewhere !!!

What do we all think !!!

 

This is my list made over Christmas.
I was reasonably happy with it until i looked on these forum's at other people's list's and noticed I'd missed some Great fighters.

Provisional top 100
1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Henry Armstrong
4. Willie Pep
5. Roberto Duran
6. Harry Greb
7. Sugar Ray Leonard
8. Ezzard Charles
9. Sam Langford
10. Joe Louis

11. Pernell Whitaker
12. Archie Moore
13. Jimmy Wilde
14. Jack Johnson
15. Carlos Monzon
16. Micky Walker
17. Julio Cesar Chavez
18. Gene Tunney
19. Benny Leonard
20. Barney Ross

21. Marvin Hagler
22. Sandy Saddler
23. Emile Griffith
24. Bob Fitzsimmons
25. Joe Gans
26. Alexis Arguello
27. Larry Holmes
28. Eder Jofre
29. Evander Holyfield
30. Tommy Hearns

30. Jose Napoles
31. Barbados Joe Walcott
32. Tony Canzoneri
33. Ike Williams
34. Lennox Lewis
35. Salvador Sanchez
36. Rocky Marciano
37. Bob Foster
38. Roy Jones jnr
39. Wifredo Gomez
40. Jimmy McLarnin

41. Fighting Harada
42. Ruben Oliveras
43. Carlos Ortiz
44. Charlie Burley
45. Manny Pacquiao
46. Dick Tiger
47. Kid Gavilan
48. Harry Wills
49. Stanley Ketchel
50. Floyd Mayweather Jnr

51. Michael Spinks
52. Ted Kid Lewis
53. Bernard Hopkins
54. Terry McGovern
55. Luis Rodriguez
56. Jackie “Kid” Berg
57. Pancho Villa
58. Joe Frazier
59. Carmen Basillio
60. George Foreman

61. Billy Conn
62. Jack Dempsey
63. Jake Lamotta
64. Holman Williams
65. Mike Tyson
66. George Dixon
67. Wilfred Benitez
68. Marcel Cerdan
69. Harold Johnson
70. Benny Lynch

71. Sonny Liston
72. Tommy Loughran
73. Lou Ambers
74. Jack Britton
75. Kid Chocolate
76. Panama Al Brown
77. Felix Trinidad
78. Ken Buchanan
79. Jimmy Bivins

80. Erik Morales
81. Marco Antonio Barrera
82. Abe Attell
83. Danny Lopez
84. Freddie Welsh
85. Oscar De La Hoya
86. Mike McCallum
87. Aaron Pryor
88. Ricardo Lopez
89. Gene Fullmer
90. Bob Montgomery

91. Shane Mosley
92. James Toney
93. Miguel Canto
94. Beau Jack
95. Hector Camacho
96. Manuel Ortiz
97. Azumah Nelson
98. Flash Elorde
99. Nicolino Locche
100.Georges Carpentier

 

Fighter's I'm still Evaluating:
Joe Calzaghe
Ismael Laguna
Carlos Zarate
Jack Dempsey "The Nonparell"
Jim Jeffries
Young Corbett III
Pasquel Perez
Kostya Tszyu
Jeff Fenech
Winky Wright
Jim Driscoll
Floyd Patterson
Jose Torres
Packey McFarland
Nino Benvenuti
Tony Zale
Rocky Graziano
Tiger Flowers
Eusebio Pedroza
Antonio Cervantes
Sam McVey

Any Thought's, is there anybody else i've Missed that warrants attention.

 

What about Ken Buchanan..... Took the title of Laguna in the heat of Panama... first person to stop Carlos Ortiz..... Was in a competative fight with Duran until he was stopped by a low blow AFTER the bell had rung,
and was never given a rematch from Duran, I think that says something

Beat many Latino fighters who ruled the LW divisions.

 

He's already in #78 on my top 100

 

Sorry must of missed it atsch

 

No Problem's, Being Scottish I'd love to have him higher, But i have try to remain impartial.


Great job of Selling Buchanan though BB.:good