Top 100 ATG - (My Personal List)

No, A Typo, Told you i was struggling.

 

MAB and Morales stay where they are on Merit.


I Hadn't thought about Pac losing to Hatton.

 

He knocked out Salvidar...Who is a HOF fighter.

Guys like Medel and Legra are worthy of HOF if blokes like Zaragoza and McGuigan are...So I dont put to much emphasis on it, the HOF is losing creditibility IMO with there glaring omissions and often bizarre admissions.

 

He is however a HOF fighter..which you seem to put a lot of emphasis on.

If you think Jofre is overrated for not beating a HOF fighter than surely you would have to reconsider that now I have pointed out he has.

 

First of all no one thinks Saldivar is his career defining win..It is what it is, he beat a near shell of Vincente but it must be said Eder was not at his best either. I only brought that up to point out that Jofre had indeed beaten a HOF
If you think that Salvidar is his career defining win just because he is the only guy Jofre beat who is in the HOF (Im havent even checked if that the case yet anyway) than it shows how much of a misguided emphasis you put on whether or not a fighter makes it into the HOF.

Im not so sure you can definitively say that he has the weakest set of victims. There is enough film and resources to gauge how good his opponants were and that can not be said of evey great fighter.

 

I think this is one of the best I've seen. It looks, for the most part, very balanced and well though-through. I do get the sense, though, that there is a bit of a slant towards heavyweights; in my opinion, Jack Johnson is considerably too high, Lennox Lewis much too high, maybe Dempsey a little high, and the Ali and Louis placements are questionable. Personally, I would have guys like Fitzsimmons and Monzon a little higher than you do, as well, but I don't think your placements are unreasonable.