Top 15 at 200lb (same day weigh-in)

Louis was better above 200lbs imo
There's no way Marciano is any less than 2. And his résumé below 200lbs shits over Holyfield's. Anyway, this is imo H2H.

1. Holyfield
2. Marciano
3. Charles
4. Spinks
5. Usyk
6. Byrd
7. Dempsey
8. Jersey Joe
9. Toney
10. Patterson
11. Schmeling
12. Moore
13. Tunney
14. Johnson
15. Langford

Fair play to Lach I forgot JJW.

 

1. Marciano
2.Tunney
3.Holyfield
4. Moore
5 Dempsey
6 Patterson
7 Walcott
8 Charles
9 Roy Jones
10 Schmeling
11 Spinks
12 Usyk
13 Harold Johnson
14 Jerry Quarry
15. Eddie Machen
Could change a few and that’s the basic order I’d put em in maybe I could be convinced to move Usyk and Jones around

 

Under 1950s ruleset:

1. Marciano
2. Dempsey
3. Louis
4. Holyfield
5. Walcott
6. Charles
7. Tunney
8. Patterson
9. Johnson
10. Moore
11. Byrd
12. Jones
13. Spinks
14. Sullivan (would be #2 or #3 under Bareknuckle)
15. Langford

 

I don't think Usyk would be making 200lbs same day weigh ins, and if he did he wouldn't be fighting very well

 

Noticing a distinct lack of Jersey Joe Walcott on your list

 

Oh shiit

Well played I forgot to re-type him, he was just below Dempsey.

 

Could Holyfield even make 200 on the same day?

 

Yeah he made 190 in the 80s

 

But didn't he have the match the next day?

 

I don't think so, I've always believed that same days weigh ins ended in the early to mid 80s, but either way I imagine Holy in 85/86 could cut from his walk around weight (which can't have been more than 210) to 200

 

Holyfield weighed 202 for his heavyweight debut against James Tillis. Yes he could make 200

 

Louis doesn't belong in the list and Marciano should be at the top.

 

I don't think the Holyfield that weighed in the 190's would far well against Louis,Dempsey and Marciano

 

I tend to think the same, but when you're talking about fighters with intangibles like these guys you'd actually have to see the fight to know for sure.