Top 20 all time p4p list in 1910?

Absolute lock for no.1: Fitz. EDIT: or Langford, how the **** did I forget him? On my P4P list Langford ranks higher, but at this level of greatness you're taking the **** picking one over another IMO.

Gans, Nonpareil, Griffo, Dixon, McGovern, Walcott, Johnson, all in the top 10.

Give me time and I can probably give you a top 10. Bit shaky on top 20 though. There was a lot of quality fighters without Championship recognition who would be right up there. Maybe Nelson would round off the top ten? Corbett, Sullivan, Jackson, Jeffries, Ketchel...wouldn't know how to split all them to be honest.

 

McGrain I edited again! And yes, McAuliffe another good shout :twisted:

 

:nono Paup Snith and Lucky Sambo were far greater fighters, mainly due to their epic 100 fight series with each other :deal

 

:huh Lucky Sambo or Young Lucky Sambo III? Because only one of them was in a gloved 100-fight series with Snith, home skillet, and it wasn't Lucky Sambo I. Trust that! :bbb

 

Come on man, Lucky Sambo is the commonly accepted moniker for Charles Reed Cane Jr, as he was the most lauded of the 8 that shared that name. You know that so don't be a pedant :fire

Not a big puncher but even if he had been it would've made no difference with Sniths legendary mandible (the Liverpudlian of course went into the ring with 300lb Greco-Roman wrestlers in exhibitions despite weighing a shade over six stone)

 

McGrain! Straighten this man out! :fire

 

Awww need help?

I wouldn't ask for McGrains, we're shitting on his thread :hey

 

See, Ears :deal

 

make that 11 times

 

For pre-1910 who are we ranking higher: Abe Attell or Young Corbett II?

 

I have Driscoll>Welsh.

 

No order(this is hard enough!):

Bob Fitzsimmons
Joe Gans
Joe Walcott
George Dixon
Young Griffo
Jack Johnson
Jim Jeffries
John L. Sullivan
Jim Corbett
Sam Langford
Stanley Ketchel
Terry McGovern
Tommy Ryan
Nonpareil Jack Dempsey
Kid McCoy
Peter Jackson
George Kid Lavigne
Abe Attell
Ike Weir
Jimmy Barry
Jack McAuliffe
Philadelphia Jack O'Brien
Jack Blackburn
Packey McFarland
Jim Driscoll

(OK, so that's 25. Too hard to cull)