Top 35 All Time reveal - Boxing Survey Series

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by Rumsfeld, Aug 2, 2020.


  1. Bujia

    Bujia Active Member Full Member

    524
    742
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Jul 2, 2020
    Jimmy McLarnin just creeping in at #35 is by far the worst thing about the list. From Flyweight to Welterweight, 16 years old to 30, he beat Flyweight champ Pancho Villa, Bantamweight champ Bud Taylor, Featherweight champ Louis “Kid” Kaplan, Lightweight champ Sammy Mandell, and Welterweight champ Young Corbett III.

    Not to mention his wins over Barney Ross, Tony Canzoneri, and Lou Ambers. In addition to many others.
     
  2. Jason Thomas

    Jason Thomas Active Member Full Member

    976
    1,044
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Feb 18, 2019
    I didn't take part because I somehow missed that this poll was going on. Us old guys sometimes miss things around us. I think it was a great idea and job by Rummy and a fine list overall.

    As an outsider, I have a couple of nitpicks. Tyson in the top 30 of all fighters I find weird and unjustifiable. I don't have a big problem with Hearns making the top 30, but I do have a problem with rating him over Hagler. Hearns fought in weight classes both below and above Hagler, but lost badly to Hagler at middle. It appears to me a fighter was penalized if his weight remained stable and so dominated one division rather than moving through several and being less dominating.

    Who should have made this top 30 and didn't. My top candidate would be Fighting Harada, a double champion who was almost a triple champion and handed Eder Jofre his only two career defeats. He should replace Tyson.

    I was interested in who had multiple victories over the top 30 guys.

    two men beaten:
    Oscar De La Hoya--Whitaker and Chavez
    Marvin Hagler--Duran and Hearns
    Jack Johnson--Langford and Fitzsimmons
    Harry Greb--Tunney and Walker
    Ezzard Charles--Louis and Moore

    Three men beaten:
    Sugar Ray Leonard--Duran, Hearns, Hagler
    Jimmy McLarnin--Benny Leonard, Ross, Canzoneri
    Rocky Marciano--Louis, Charles, Moore

    Did I miss someone?

    Top ten only.

    Two wins:
    Jack Johnson
    Rocky Marciano

    All but Johnson and Charles of the men who beat two of the top 30 also lost to someone in the top 30.

    Of the men who beat three of the top 30, Leonard lost to Duran and had a draw with Hearns. McLarnin lost twice to Ross and once to Canzoneri.

    Marciano is unique in going 4-0 against the #5, #10, & #13 men and knocking them all out without losing to anyone. Looking at it this way does make a case that he perhaps should have been in the top 30 despite a short career.
     
    Last edited: Sep 2, 2020
  3. cuchulain

    cuchulain Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    26,977
    1,694
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Jan 6, 2007
    Won't hurt Roy's in the long run either.

    I think his stock will rise with time.

    (after he retires. :D )
     
    Rumsfeld likes this.
  4. cuchulain

    cuchulain Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    26,977
    1,694
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Jan 6, 2007
    He was.

    (in my list. :))
     
  5. Webbiano

    Webbiano Boxing Junkie Full Member

    7,940
    938
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Nov 6, 2011
    I’m ok with Robinson at 1, I just feel like Greb and Langford got a bit hard done by with the lack of 1st place votes for them.

    Cheers @Rumsfeld & all the participating posters. It’s been a blast
     
    Rumsfeld likes this.
  6. Webbiano

    Webbiano Boxing Junkie Full Member

    7,940
    938
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Nov 6, 2011
    Great post, hard to disagree with any of them nit picks.
     
    Rumsfeld likes this.
  7. Gudetama

    Gudetama Active Member Full Member

    947
    769
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Sep 11, 2017
    ATG list is pretty good! Probably the best one, all in all?
    Appreciate Rummy organizing everything, and all of us who contributed, for better or worse! Really glad to be part of it.
    Recently I've been making a top 100 football/soccer player list with just one good friend, and it's been a bloody nightmare! So I was really happy to be part of this major project.
    Good job, I think. Thanks again for letting me join. Take care, all!
     
  8. cuchulain

    cuchulain Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    26,977
    1,694
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Jan 6, 2007
    @Rumsfeld, did you mention earlier that you were going to repost everybody's lists ?
    (All who participated , that is.)
     
    Rumsfeld and PhillyPhan69 like this.
  9. Jel

    Jel Reserving the right to be inconsistent Full Member

    4,219
    5,886
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Oct 20, 2017
    Is this the name and shame part of the survey?
     
    George Crowcroft and Webbiano like this.
  10. cuchulain

    cuchulain Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    26,977
    1,694
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Jan 6, 2007
    No.

    Are you telling us that some participants should be ashamed of their lists ?
     
  11. Jel

    Jel Reserving the right to be inconsistent Full Member

    4,219
    5,886
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Oct 20, 2017
    No, it was a tongue in cheek question.
     
  12. mcvey

    mcvey Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    91,890
    18,363
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Jun 2, 2006
    Huge thank you to Rummy for all his time and effort in making this happen!
     
  13. cuchulain

    cuchulain Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    26,977
    1,694
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Jan 6, 2007
    So was the response. ;)
     
  14. DrederickTatum

    DrederickTatum We really outchere. Full Member

    810
    800
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Mar 20, 2020
    Only watched the top 25 P4P, but someone didn't rank Joe Louis at HW, Ezzard Charles at LHW and Roberto Duran P4P?

    C'mon own up, who did the dirty?

    Shocked Greb or Langford didn't get number 1.

    Great stuff btw @Rumsfeld, I'll definitely be watching more of your videos.
     
    Last edited: Sep 4, 2020
    Rumsfeld and Jel like this.
  15. Jel

    Jel Reserving the right to be inconsistent Full Member

    4,219
    5,886
    Sportsbook:
    1,000
    Oct 20, 2017
    I'm not surprised Greb or Langford didn't make no. 1. It's only a relatively recent supposition that they are greater than Robinson and "mainstream" boxing publications have been pronouncing Robinson as unequivocally no. 1 for 60 years so it is hard to break free from that thinking.

    The idea of Robinson as the greatest of all time isn't going to change overnight and in Greb's case in particular, rightly or wrongly, it is hard for people to rate him at no. 1 and yet never have seen him fight. That almost certainly hampers him in these lists.
     
    Rumsfeld likes this.