Some of these fighters that our aussie fighters stepped up to the block to challenge, were monumental efforts...they were not losers. Tony Mundine v Carlos Monson Paul Ferreri V Carlos Zarate Hector Thomson V Roberto Duran
Look forward to seeing your list Contendo - because it's one hard assignment and nobody's list will be 'correct' as such. I've always rated Barry Michael's effort against Al 'Earthquate' Carter as awesome. I was at the Michael Ellis bout and certainly rate that highly as well. Probably never enjoyed a bout more than 'Hitman' Harding and Andries. But how does Andries rate as an opponent compared to Judah, Lesnevich, Nelson etc? Loved all of Fenech's fights - was a huge fan. Callejas and Zaragoza were standouts - but for me Nelson was his career best performance because of the quality of his opponent. See how you go fitting 30 into 10 mate.
In fact Duran, when asked who the hardest puncher he'd ever faced was, said 'that Australian fellow Thompson'. Hec certainly hurt him early on.
Hey CHB, comments above. Also, I suppose I rate bouts on their significance and overall appeal. Andries was a great fighter and very worthy opponent, we have to remember he went 10 of 12 with Thomas 'The Hitman' Hearns so it makes it hard when judging on calibre of opponent only. Some of Andries opponents were very worthy fighters. I just personally felt Harding's win was against the odd's, big stage, big opponent, late notice / grab the opportunity, come from behind / underdog stuff, yet he fought a hard, tough fight right till the end. It embodied everything you want to see in a fighter and I suppose that's why it's a Top 5 Aussie fight for sure in my opinion. The Barry Michael/Lester Ellis fight just had all the theatre of what a fight should be and the fight itself let no one down. Whilst appreciating Barry's 'Carter' performance, it's not often you get two Aussie fighters actually fighting for a fair dinkum world-title and both Barry and Lester delivered in spades. I was always disapointed that things never worked out (timing/life changes/weight classes not quite there at respective times in either's career) and Fenech never got to face either Lester or Barry in a big stoush. Just not to be I suppose.
No seriously pal, you won't be getting one from me as I genuinally haven't seen enough of the old footage to do it justice. I respect all the old fighters and their achievements in some cases probably hold more weight due to only being two titles (WBA / WBC) 'back in the day'. It takes nothing away from the achievements and performances of modern day fighters, just circumstances are vastly different. One we all haven't mentioned - Michael Katisidis vs. Graham Earl. Massive fight, massive stage, massive performance.
See I'd honestly rate Mick's efforts against Casamayor and Marquez as greater, because his opposition was so much better. The Earl fight was a ripper though.
None of us are really qualified to make the call mate, that's half the fun of it. Even Grant Kieza & Ray Wheatley, who've gone into print on this, have offered a list most of us would pick holes in (rightly or wrongly). Incidentally they had Michael vs Lester at 22, and Mundine vs Green one postion higher at 21. Many would argue the positioning of those two bouts - I'd certaily have them the other way around - but hey, it's all a matter of opinion.
I had the JMM fight highly also Ippy, simply due to a great performance against a lock hall-of-fame fighter.
A little off topic, as I was young and really didn't know about the 'behind the scenes' of what goes into making a fight (probably some would say I still don't know!), is there any real reason why a Fenech vs. either Michael or Ellis never eventuated? I know the obvious people are going to say is weight classes, but is that the only reason why a non-title 'catchweight' fight was never agreed too? I know Mordey at times had Fenech in non-title fights to keep him ticking over (and the $) and Jeff would always be a little heavier. Can anyone shed any light or is it just simply the weight and timing thing and my hope was just a flipant, never a remote chance dream!