Top 5 atgs in each division

175:

1.) Ezzard Charles
2.) Archie Moore
3.) Bob Foster
4.) Michael Spinks
5.) Tommy Loughran

130:

1.) Alexis Arguello
2.) Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3.) Julio Cesar Chavez
4.) Azumah Nelson
5.) Bobby Chacon (EDIT: originally Genaro Hernandez [RIP])

 

Heavyweight-Muhammed Ali.Cruiser-Evander holyfield,Middle-Marvin Hagler,Welter-Ray Robinson and Light-Roberto Duran.

 

I'd definitely make the top 5 heavyweights Muhammad Ali, Joe Louis, Jack Johnson, Rocky Marciano and Lennox Lewis, order of the latter 3 depending on criteria.

 

HW - Ali, Louis, Lennox, Holmes, Wlad.
LHW - Charles, Tunney, Moore, Loughran, Spinks
MW - Greb, Monzon, Hagler, Hopkins, Fitzsimmons
WW - Robinson, Walker, Armstrong, Leonard, Gavalin
LW - Leonard, Gans, Duran, Williams, Ortiz
FW - Pep, Saddler, Chocolate, Dixon, Attel
BW - Jofre, McGovern, Harada, Olivares, Brown
Fly - Wilde, Canto, Parez, Villa, Wolgast

 

Seriously Wlad a top 5 all time not in a million years .Otherwise good choices

 

I was torn between him and Foreman.
Wlad doesn't have 2 wins as good as Norton and Frazier, but he does has a lot of good wins.

Underrated Era imo.

 

At least its different.
H
Ali
Johnson
Dempsey
Louis
Holmes

LH
Tunney
Charles
Langford
Moore
Foster

M
Greb
Monzon
Robinson
Hagler
Tiger

W
Leonard
Hearns
Napoles
Whitaker
Griffith

L
Leonard
Gans
Williams
Duran
Armstrong

F
Pep
Saddler
Sanchez
Attell
Arguello

B
Jofre
Olivares
Zarate
Harada

F
Wilde
Lynch
Canto
Perez
Chitalada

 

By: Y. Truly


Heavyweight:

1. James J. Jeffries
2. Jack A. Johnson
3. Sir J. Dempsey
4. John L. Sullivan
5. James J. Corbett

Light Heavyweight:

1. Bob J. Fitszimmons
2. Goat S. Langford
3. Kid McCoy
4. Tom E. Burns
5. Gene Tunney

Middleweight:

1. Stanley Ketchel
2. Philadephia J. O'Brien
3. Nonpareil J. Dempsey
4. Harry Greb
5. Mars L. Cerdan

Welterweight:

1. Barbados J. Walcott
2. Sugar R. Robinson
3. Tommy Ryan
4. Micky Walker
5. Young J. Thompson

Lightweight:

1. Joe Gans
2. Jack McFuffle
3. Packey McFuffle
4. Benny Leonard
5. Bruce Lee

Featherweight:

1. Terrible T. McGovern
2. Willie Pepé
3. Johnny Dundee
4. Jim Driscoll
5. Young C. II

Bantamweight:

1. George Dixon
2. Pete Herman
3. Johnny F. Coulon
4. Kid Williams
5. Joseph A. Lynch

Flyweights:

1. Jimmy Barry
2. Fidel L. Barba'
3. Jimmy B. Wilde
4. Benjamin Lynch
5. Frank F. Genaro

 

At least its different.
H
Ali
Johnson
Dempsey
Louis
Holmes

LH
Tunney
Charles
Langford
Moore
Foster

M
Greb
Monzon
Robinson
Hagler
Ketchel

W
Leonard
Hearns
Napoles
Gavilan
Griffith

L
Leonard
Gans
Williams
Duran
Armstrong

F
Pep
Saddler
Sanchez
Arguello
Pedroza

B
Jofre
Olivares
Zarate
Perez
Brown

F
Wilde
Lynch
Canto
Kane

 

Top 5 per division - original 8

Heavy:
Ali
Louis
Holmes
Johnson
Marciano

Light heavy:
Charles
Moore
Tunney
Loughran
Foster

Middle:
Greb
Monzon
Hagler
Ketchel
Walker

Welter:
Robinson
Leonard
Napoles
Armstrong
Gavilan

Light:
Leonard
Duran
Gans
Williams
Ortiz

Feather:
Pep
Saddler
Saldivar
Attell
Sanchez

Bantam:
Jofre
Ortiz
Olivares
Harada
Zarate

Fly:
Wilde
Canto
Perez
Lynch
Genaro

 

Top 5 per division - betweener divisions

Cruiser:
Holyfield
Usyk
Mormeck
DeLeon
Haye

Super middleweight:
Calzaghe
Ward
Jones
Toney
Froch

Junior middle:
Hearns
McCallum
Wright
Benitez
Trinidad

Junior Welter:
Chavez
Cervantes
Pryor
Locche
Tszyu

Junior light:
Arguello
Mayweather
Nelson
Chavez
Elorde

Junior feather:
Gomez
Morales
Barrera
Fenech
McKinney

Junior Bantam:
Roman
Galaxy
Tapia
Watanabe
Moon

Junior Fly:
C. Gonzalez
Carbajal
Chang
Gushiken
Yuh

Straw:
Lopez
Calderon
R. Gonzalez
Alvarez
Porpaoin

 

I feel Hearns would have beaten Gavilan, Armstrong and Walker, Armstrong`s style with his reach would be suicide against a welter Hearns, this wasn`t the same Tommy that struggled with Roldan and Barkley as they rushed in.

 

Canelo is better than Trinidad was at at 160 and was maybe better than Felix at 154 also.