I'm sure theres been top 10 lists, but let's just narrow it to the top 5. An easy order imo: 1. Duran 2. Monzon 3. Chavez 4. Jofre 5. Ortiz/Arguello interchangeable.
1. Roberto Duran 2. Eder Jofre 3. Carlos Monzon 4. Carlos Ortiz 5. Jose Napoles 6. Kid Gavilan 7. Alexis Arguello 8. Julio Cesar Chavez 9. Luis Rodriguez 10. Ruben Olivares
1. Roberto Duran 2. Carlos Ortiz 3. Chavez 4. Monzon 5. Napoles 6. Arguello 7. Kid Gavilan 8. Salvador Sanchez 9. Ruben Olivares 10. Wilfred Benitez I can't rate Ortiz lower than 2, his resume is insane.
His resume is brilliant and he was a complete fighter. I tend to think Napoles was a “better fighter” but when I factor it in I have Ortiz slightly ahead of him.
I think Napoles was better than both Arguello and Ortiz, but he does rank behind both in greatness. I'd definitely have Napoles at 6.