Top 5 p4p mma fighters ?

1. Fedor
2. A.Silva
3. GSP
4. Penn

5th is a hard pick for me. It wouldn't be justice to anyone if i pick 1.

 

This would be my list aswell. Although at the moment some of the smaller guys like Torres and Faber i think could also easily be in the 5th spot aswell.

 

1. Fedor
2. Anderson Silva
3. Penn
4. GSP
5. Faber

 

That's a pretty solid list. Mine could easily look like that. However - I'll go with a sleeper P4P candidate for my #5 spot:

1) Fedor
2) Anderson Silva
3) Randy Couture
4) BJ Penn
5) Cung Le

 

Hmm. Ok Cung Le is good. BUT he hasn't done anything at all that warrant him a place in the p4p top 10 let alone top 5.

 

I can't disagree with you - but it's my unofficial rankings so I reserve the right to rank Cung Le where I like.

When he beats Anderson Silva you'll all change your mind. :bbb

 

Jackie Chan should be ranked above Jet Li.

 

Why? Has Jet Li forgotten how to fight?

 

No. Jackie Chan should be ranked higher because Jet Li trained in Wu Shu which is the watered down flashier versions of Kung Fu - whereas Jackie trained in the real deal - Wing Chun, Tiger claw, etc. . . Therefore Jackie would tear Jet Li a new one.

 

Fiar enough. But i think you'll waiting a while.

 

having Couture and Le there and not GSP is a joke, in my opinion. Forrest Griffin deserve more a place in the top 5 than Couture or Le


1.Fedor
2. Anderson Silva
3. Georges St. Pierre
4. BJ Penn
5. Miguel Torres

 

I knew that would **** people off - but that's the way I feel about it. I left GSP off because he lost to Serra. Silva, Couture, and Penn move up and down the scale winning fights - which in my mind is what a P4P fighter should do. I don't think GSP would beat Cung Le - so that's why my list looks as it does.

 

Cung Le is a good figher yes, but he would never beat GSP. He needed three round to TKO glass jaw Morgan and that was a body shot if I remember, he wont knock GSP, he lacks power, and even if he have some wrestling credentials, GSP will just murder him on the ground and Le will never be able to prevent him from being taken down, even if GSP is a welterweight he wont get outpowered by Le. GSP TKO 2 by GnP

 

I agree with the statement about GSP being below Silva and BJ and maybe Couture. However GSP should be in the top 5 and i don't think Cung Le would be able to beat GSP. He hasn't done anything to prove he could hang with a guy like GSP or even the top guys at Middleweight (yet).