Top 5 P4P Of All-Time Based On Talent/Ability - Completely Disregarding Resume?

In no particular order:

Sugar Ray Robinson
Sugar Ray Leonard
Roberto Duran
Roy Jones Jr
Salvador Sanchez
Gene Tunney

A little unorthodox, and I know there's 6 names, but that's what I'm rolling with today. I've been playing Fallout 3 for 12 hours straight so that's as good as it's getting.

 

Thanks, he was one of the first people I thought of when I saw that resume didn't play a part. It's a shame because he really had a great resume as well for no longer than he had to fight; sure, he fought down to lesser opponents, but he was also the definition of a "big fight" fighter as well. I'm too young to have seen him live, but after getting his career set, the sharpness and composure he had in his biggest fights despite being so young was just phenomenal. Special, special fighter.


Edit: I think I'd replace Tunney with Bob Fitzsimmons if I had it to do over again, as well.

 

1. Sugar Ray Leonard
2. Sugar Ray Robinson
3. Muhammad Ali
4. Roy Jones Jr
5. Willie pep