Top 6,000 P4P List

I agree. I did my own top 100 because my grandad bought me "Henry Cooper's 100 Greatest Boxers" when I was a wee boy and it was always an ambition to write my own century. But even I was shocked at someone writing a top 400. I just think it's pretty weird to be honest. I mean, what is the point??

 

10 ten is all that's needed to show who's the cream of the crop in peoples opinions. I think there fun but people can easily get carried away into thinking there official.

 

Your cousin could get in on the list, duhhh.

 

Pound for pound ain't a perfect system anyway,mor so it's flawed in many pieces.

 

I actually want see someone do a 6000 list now, just for the **** of it, haha.

 

My thoughts exactly. It's pointless. How can you decide between the guy who is 383rd and the guy who is 384th? Arbitrary placings.

The guy who made the list must be aching to be noticed and rated. It smacks of desperation to me in all honesty.

 

I agree. I thought it was ridiculous when I saw that thread in the Classic.

 

Damn top 6000..i gotta top 125..thats the best i can do n still be legit wit it!

 

6001 - Charlie Zelenoff

 

6002 - Jerry Hackney

[YT]W_A77xlV4U4[/YT]

 

:rofl:rofl:rofl

I honestly opened up this thread expecting to see 6000 names and I was going to put you straight on my ignore list Tommy

Yeah there's really no need for more than ten. You can start bracketing people together after that.

As for your top 5, I have Cotto above Mosely and Izzy above B-Hop but other than that the same.

 

Yeah...there might be a point making a list of the B+ to A level fighters, but that's about it. Once you get down to the C and D level...what the hell is the point, even if you could indeed argue cogently that number 350 is definitely better than number 375.

 

I saw the list the top 20 alone was fail