Top Ten at 168?

Kessler
Jermaine Taylor
Carl Froch
Lucian Bute
Librado Andrade
Sakio Bika
Anthony Mundine


The rest, whatever..

 

Kessler
Froch
Bute
Taylor
Andrade
Inkin
Bika
Mundine
Pascal
Zuniga

 

Mundine has left SMW.

 

Kessler
Taylor
Bika
Mundine
Dirrell
Green
Ward
Froch
Bute
Inkin

 

Pop Direll in at 10 then I guess.

 

1.Kessler
2.Bute
3.Taylor
4.Forch
5.Bika
6.Inkin
7.Mundine
8.Andrade
9.Lacy
10.Dirrel

 

Lol Bute on second and andrade on 8th. Bute lost renember. I recon ur from Canada or Romania or just simple not a boxing fan

 

Mundine is middleweight, please leave him out of future lists.

 

I haven't seen the Taylor v. Lacy fight, unfortunately, so I cannot comment on Taylor's performance...but beating Lacy in itself is no feat.

Anyway, Taylor has the skills to be in the Top 3 at SMW, so, leaving him out, I have:

Kessler
Bute
Andrade*
Inkin
Bika

...the rest...I'm not sure what order they'd follow in: Froch, Tsypko, Berrio, Larsen, Dirrell, Pascal, Sartison, Green etc. or even if all of them are indeed Top 10...some might slot somewhere in between the 5 above, some might not...most are unproven or not obviously Top 10 (e.g. Berrio), so there's no much point in ranking them.

*Andrade slots in just after Bute, in any case, because he was just a couple of short of stopping him...a rematch is needed to clarify who is indeed the superior fighter.

 

Agree

 

Oh, dear...that is one bad list...thunder and Armele Romane won't be pleased!:verysad

 

Mundine is a MW...Pascal...is he in the Top 10 because he faces Froch next?:hey Zuniga is NOT a Top 10 fighter, by any means...:verysad; Froch at 2? Why not at 1? :huh

Come on, Liam, you're much better than that!

 

Well I agreed above to drop Mundine... Frankly after Inkin and Bika there is a big drop off. You really think Tsypko, Berrio, and Sartison are certainly better than Pascal and Zuniga? I cant see it, maybe Sartison. Basically there is a top 7 or 8 and also rans/prospects. Pascal looks quite skilled if untested and Zuniga has beaten (an old) Echols and taken Inkin the distance. I wouldnt argue with him being swapped for say Berio or Sartison say but I dont see any great difference in them.

Obviously I am ranking Froch on my estimation of his H2H ability not achievment.

 

For sure, mate! For sure! Berrio and Tsypko are definitely better than Zuniga. Pascal is just unproven, but with his chin, you'd have to fancy Berrio's chances. Tsypko could outbox him too, probably. Pascal could be Top 10, but he could be as modest as Top 25 too...there's no way of knowing, and ranking him in the Top 10 is wishful thinking at this stage, unfortunately.

Inkin just did enough to win. I'm not saying Inkin's a wordbeater either, but he is a Top 10 fighter, at least until proven otherwise.

But why do you rank him at 2? If he is the indestructible monster that you make him out to be by ranking him over some very good proven fighters, when he's not even proven to be a world class fighter, why not rank him straight at No 1? And why not rank someone like Dirrell high up too...he looks unbeatable against mediocre opposition too...for different reasons...