top20 p4p according to a panel of 28 boxing writers

I'd have Marquez (if he goes back to 135) and Mosley over Williams for sure. Dawson and Hopkins too. Probably Ward and Donaire too. Williams can find his place in the lower top10.

I think Bute is pretty close to being top10 p4p (say what you wanna say about him but you can make a case he is just as good as Ward and he redeemed himself for the Andrade fight which he won anyways). So are JuanMa, Abraham, Bradley, Vitali, Chris John, Cotto, Wlad and Gamboa. I guess Martinez and Kessler can be with that bunch too.

Its very subjective of course. Sometimes its hard to see who is better than who because the best fights don't always get made. You gotta go with your gut a little bit.

I'll post my top20 later

 

I always do all my p4p rankings based on how good I believe the fighters are.

 

1. Pac

2. PBF

3. JMM (@ 135, not if he campaigns @ 140 and definately not @147)

4. Mosley

5. Hopkins

6. Donaire

7. Ward

8. Williams

9. Vitali

10. Dawson

11. Wlad

12. Cotto

13. Bute

14. Abraham

15. Sergio Martinez

16. Chris John

17. Tim Bradley

18. JuanMa Lopez

19. Kessler

20. Josh Clottey

Just missed the cut: Yuriorkis Gamboa.

BTW I really wanted to put Rigondeaux in there cause I think he's already got it but I'll wait till he fights someone with a pulse.

Also for those who think Wlad is better than Vitali get a grip even this version of Vitali who is getting old is still better than Wlad even though I gotta give credit to Wlad who has improved alot.

 

He lost a CLOSE ass fight to Calzaghe when Calzaghe was one of the best fighters in the world and he beat the ****ing crap out of Pavlik who was not really that much smaller than Hopkins who is also a career SMW with just a couple of fights above 160. Say what you wanna say about Hopkins being old and boring but the truth remains that this mutha****a is HARD TO BEAT.