top20 p4p according to a panel of 28 boxing writers

It's fairly laughable. Haye is former linear cruiserweight champion and now a title holder at heavyweight whereas Clottey's best win is against the remnants of Zab Judah. WTF?

 

Since Ward dominated a top rate opponent in his last fight and Froch skated by with a questionable decision against an inferior opponent.

I have Ward several spots ahead of Froch.


Keith

 

atsch The Judah who was probably only 60% of what he was when he fought Mayweather is better than Enzo Maccarnelli, Jean Marc Mormeck, and Giacobbe Fragomeni?

 

Donaire, Calderon out of top 10..P.Williams #3...no Adamek...**** list
It must be noted 85% of American writers also picked Lacy to destroy Calzaghe

 

Originally I thought PW was ranked too high, but after reading through this thread, I think it is a fair enough ranking.

No one else(that were ranked below him) is doing enough in recent times to be rated above him.

 

I guess Paul Williams fans should scream now very loudly!

 

Please. Everyone always uses that same fight as an excuse to discredit American writers.


Enough already. They ****ed around and got one wrong. So what? 85% of them also Kessler over Ward.

 

If the majority disagrees, saying there is no debate is just dumb. Ward is also coming off those wins back to back?

Ward has two notable wins, one of them over the #1 in the division while Froch has debatable win over Dirrell (not even ranked by the RING), a knockout after getting dominated against Taylor (whose only win is Jeff Lacy.. Jeff Lacy!) and a good win against Pascal. That's one good win, two average wins whereas Ward has one great win, one good one. Beating the #1 alone should do the trick for him.

 

It really does feel that way. Like Nonito Donaire with the RING.

The biggest problem here is that PW is #3 though. He is borderline top 10 for me.

 

Paul Williams is easily the most overrated fighter ever.

 

Unbiased PWill fan, right?

 

Where would you rate him?