Tito would be terribly drained, so Cotto. However, Tito could still hurt Miguel badly and finish him, so it would be a fight that you would get the feeling that anything could happen.
This question should be asked after Cotto's next two fights ... 1. the Margarito-Williams winner and 2. Any 1 of Hatton/Mayweather/Mosley/DeLaHoya ... Winning two of those potential fights would solidify his status among the best, and the answer to the "Cotto-Trinidad" debate would be unanimous ... Trinidad is coming back, why not just let them settle it in the ring.
also Cotto's best punch is his left....Tito's best punch is his left hook.... this means Cotto will be trading left hooks with trinidad who has an astounding ability to throw his shots at the same time as his opponents ...trading left hooks with tito is suicide Tito's will land and decapitate Cotto over and over until he is out cold...
Many would think that Trinidad is finished and Cotto would kill him. On the other hand, Cotto's style fits Trinidad, like Vargas and Mayorga's did. Not that I should compare Cotto to Vargas and Mayorga, but I doubt that a bout between Cotto and Trinidad today would not be an easy win for Cotto.
There's always some ****ing stupid newb who comes trying to get attention... Welcome attention *****.:finger5