I'd be putting some serious money on Troy Waters to easily outpoint Mundine. Troy Watrs is one of the best fighters we've had and is seriously under-rated these days
Guy was a better boxer but Jeff the better fighter....... Both at their best ill go with Harding. Troy was easily the best out of the brothers. Troy - world class Guy - just short of world class although fought a lot of great fighters Dean - domestic heavy
Lets compare performances - Bones Kelly struggled with a raw as **** on short notice inexperienced sam soliman,Mundine detroyed soliman in his prime. Which Waters did mundine beat ?
Anyone watch the fight between Felix Trinidad and Troy?...Most were suprised with the result,so that says how much talent Troy had
Do you following boxing at all? Mundine beat a shell in Guy Waters who was about 38yrs at the time. Mundine got KO'd by Garth Woods......... Soliman beat Woods :nut So what's your point again :huh
Haven't seen the Bones-Soliman fight...but the scores were unanimously wide and it's a fight Soliman admits he lost clearly.
troy had a car crash and had a metal plate inserted in his head before the trinidad fight, if my memory serves me correctly..? one could argue that troy was a damaged fighter when he fought felix..
Mundine way too fast and classy for Waters. Waters probably as good as Green which means Mundine wins easy, probably toys with him like he did with Green. Waters showed massive courage against Norris, but if you take out the knockdown he got well and truly punished, lost count of how many times he hit the deck. Look at ring mags annual top ten rankings, Mundine #3 for 4 years, 2 more years top 5 and 2 more top 10. Waters just one year ranked 10 says it all.
Waters had problems with good boxers Rossi out box Waters,Choc would be a nightmare for troy with his footwork and speed,late round KO or unanimous decision for Choc...
the troy waters that fought on the fenech vs payakaroon undercard would have destroyed the 'ottke' mundine.
A weak Mundine at 154lbs doesn't stand a chance and gets stopped. At 168lbs its the reverse and Troy losses on the cards maybe even by stoppage. At 160lbs :think