Jack, I congratulate you for sticking to your word and watching the fight and getting specific. I went straight to round 10, because that's where you refer to the most vicious and most obvious deliberate head-butt. [ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJJa_a4YJUE&feature=related[/ame] at 2:06 of round 10, a head-butt occurs. How you determine this to be deliberate is not clear. Ward is closing the distance to get out of no-mans land, and he rushes forward. Kessler has just missed with a right and his head is down. They collide. I can definitely see that Ward is more at fault because he rushes forward. But deliberate? As in: "now I'm going to crack him with my head, even though I'm kicking his ass with my fists! Just for the heck of it and because I'm a dirty!"? No. Zero evidence for that. I'll let the fair-minded ESB readers go and look for themselves. 2:06 of round 10.
It would not have to have been in Denmark for him to be dq'd for what he did in that fight. It would just have to have a referee that knows the rules and can see. He was beating him before he did the stuff that would have dq'd him though.
I understand what you're saying and, like I said, if you look at 2 or 3, you could say it could be an accident. However, this same thing happened throughout the fight. By round 10, Ward knew that every time he moved his head in that direction, there was a clash of heads, yet he still did it. As the fight progressed, he lunged in harder and faster. Whether he was actually thinking "Right, I'm gonna headbutt him right now" is obviously impossible to say. However, did he know he was going to connect? I think we can all agree on that. Maybe saying it was deliberate is harsh. One thing I would stand by, is that he was deliberately careless. If he was getting cut off these headbutts, no way would so many have occurred. Had he been warned, he could have stopped them from happening so often too.
the ref could have done a better job. Ward's head is all over the place, not unlike Tim Bradley and Hopkins. They lunge when they punch. It's not deliberate but it's a head-butt prone style. Oh yeah, lost in the discussion is the following fact: Ward comprehensively outboxed Kessler.
Honestly, I see why people praise Ward highly. He has a good style but I think he makes a lot of mistakes too. The amount of times he leaps in with absolutely no defence, isn't good. Sooner or later, when he fights someone that doesn't have a big gap between offence and defence, he's going to get tagged on the way in, time and time again. Looking at a few Froch fights, that's one thing I think may play a big part. Watch Froch stroll casually around the ring, hands down with his chin behind his shoulder. He's open to anything you can imagine but as soon as the opponent strikes, he counters. That's dangerous for Ward and he must avoid the counter right uppercut because he has zero defence against it, when lunging in. The key for Ward right now though, is his jab. It's his best shot and when he throws the left from a southpaw stance, that seems hard to figure out. However, whilst he does have a lot going for him, he must be careful. He's not really evasive, he can be hurt and at times he forgets defence altogether. Against someone like Froch, that could be a worry for him. Froch/Ward/Bute are the clear elite at 168 though, even if neither Ward or Bute have a resume to match Froch's. I think all three can beat each other.
Andre Fraud without his personal ref letting him head-butt, hold and elbow will be a completely different fighter. He won't know what to do.