Tyson vs Holyfield 1, Holyfield should have been disqualified (Not because of headbutts)

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by NewChallenger, Feb 13, 2024.


  1. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Member Full Member

    344
    308
    Oct 17, 2020
    Mike when he fought Holyfield the 2nd time,he would have lost regardless. He just had the wrong gameplan and he couldn't win this way. In the 3rd round of Fight 2,he did go back to the Fight 1 gameplan, which is why he started winning, and which is why Evander went back to the reason why he should have been disqualified in Fight 1.

    I don't understand how incompetent Mitch Halpern was in the 1st fight, it has nothing to do with the headbutting. It's just that Evander held like 10 times in the first round,and it was ALWAYS when Mike landed anything of substance, when he ,Evander was landing, he had no problem to just stand and actually fight. I feel like he held so much during this fight that he should have been disqualified or atleast have points taken away where he would stop the constant holding.

    I don't know if anyone here agrees, but this is what I think was the reason why Mike Lost the 1st fight, the 2nd fight, he would have lost because the headbutting would have lead to the ear bite and his gameplan was wrong.
     
  2. Ney

    Ney Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,202
    10,639
    Feb 13, 2024
    Well, imagine how many fights Ali would have been DQ’d in were they to realistically police holding.
     
    Smoochie, robert ungurean and Rollin like this.
  3. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Member Full Member

    344
    308
    Oct 17, 2020
    There is a difference as Ali actually didn't just hold the guy IMMIDIATLY after he got hit. He got hit by George for instance in Zaire plenty, and he did tie him up, but literally EVERY SINGLE punch Mike landed on evander lead to a clinch.
     
  4. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,559
    24,787
    Jun 26, 2009
    Lol — Mike Tyson is undefeated all-time if you just put an asterisk behind every loss.

    Holy manhandled the man child. Some people still can’t accept what they can plainly see on film.
     
  5. Melankomas

    Melankomas Prime Jeffries would demolish a grizzly in 2 Full Member

    6,109
    7,405
    Dec 18, 2022
    I'd say there's a better claim for DQing Evander for those sneaky headbutts.
     
  6. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Member Full Member

    344
    308
    Oct 17, 2020
    Did I not just say he would lose the 2nd fight? Mike's biggest problem was that he wasn't an inside fighter. So there Evander could have beaten him that way.
    If Evander fought Mike in his prime, and he was allowed to do the same tactic he did in fight 1, Evander would have won, because Mike can't fight that way. My problem is that , I don't think Evander would have beaten Mike the 1st time if Evander was penalized for the holding. You can literally look at the fight and see Evander be very brave and being a warrior when he gets to land punch after punch on Mike, but the second mike lands 1 shot, he literally just holds on for dear life and just keeps doing it until he hurts Mike, which Mike even in the round where he was getting beat up in the 10th, he did not do this. After like 10 unanswered punches. Evander takes 1 hit and he holds on for dear life.

    It's like, why are you not being disqualitifed for this?
     
  7. sauhund II

    sauhund II Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,494
    2,186
    Nov 8, 2008
    I like this game..........

    Bowe manhandled the PED Headbutt expert, twice, gave him a a career beating in one and knocked his azz face down and out in the third.

    Huggybear Ruiz manhandled the PED Headbutt expert, lol, he even threw knees in that one, 1-1-1..............some people still can't accept what they can plainly see on film.
     
  8. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Member Full Member

    344
    308
    Oct 17, 2020
    I do feel like there was major bias when it came to the refs in these fights. Because I have seen other fights were Mike would headbutt someone by accident, recently I saw him fight Tucker, and Mike ( Ibelieve it was teh 9th round) was going in fro a left hook,and you can see Mike's glove is in between him and tucker's face, and Tucker rushes forward crashing into Mike, and Mills Lane gives Mike the **** for that.

    Mike did dumb **** too, forearms and elbows. But I guarantee you, that the way that Evander headbutts, Even just being done gently hurts like a mother****er
     
  9. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,559
    24,787
    Jun 26, 2009
    Because you’re making an assumption that if warned or penalized, Evander would have continued to do the same thing and been DQ’d? Which I seriously doubt is the case.

    Take a really close look at the film again and you’ll see it’s not always Evander grabbing and holding. On the inside, Mike has a habit of thrusting one or both arms forward, which means he’s cooperating with the clinch. If he keeps his hands not against Evander’s sides under his armpits, there’s no clinch. And how many times does he have a free hand and not punch with it, forcing the ref to break them? It’s more complex than just ‘Evander holding.’ Tyson is a participant in it more cases than not. If you put your arm between my arm and my torso, there’s going to be a clinch unless I reach for the sky (which no boxer is going to do) to avoid it. That’s how clinches usually happen.

    Perhaps Mike should throw more than one punch at a time and not fall inside with his arm or arms out.

    Excessive holding is not the same as clinching — clinches happen, and almost always both are at ‘fault.’ And it’s not against the rules for two guys to tie up.

    But back to my original point: If the ref warns Holyfield to the point of penalizing, II expect that Evander is going to adjust rather than keep doing it. So he wouldn’t be DQ’d. And I don’t think Mike necessarily (or even likely) beats him if that happens. (Of course Mike got warned and penalized for ear-biting, yet he went right back and bit Evander again as soon as they resumed, so you never know.)
     
  10. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,559
    24,787
    Jun 26, 2009
    Nobody is disputing Holyfield lost those fights.

    Yet with Mike it’s …

    “He didn’t lose to Evander really, he got butted.”

    “He didn’t really lose to Buster, see, he had sex and didn’t train hard.”

    “He didn’t lose to Lennox, he was just old.” (Even though Mike gave up a belt rather than face Lewis when Lennox was his mandatory, lol.)

    “He was way past it when those journeymen beat his ass, so those don’t count either.”

    Just put an asterisk by all his losses and there you have it: Undefeated Mike Tyson.

    This much has always been true and always will be true in sport, and there’s no getting around it:

    Losers make excuses. Winners adjust.
     
    young griffo, zadfrak, Mike_b and 2 others like this.
  11. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Member Full Member

    344
    308
    Oct 17, 2020
    And no,if Evander was not holding, he wouldn't just "adjust" because that was literally the entire gameplan.
     
  12. Saintpat

    Saintpat Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    22,559
    24,787
    Jun 26, 2009
    Tell me YDKSAB without telling me you don’t know squat about boxing, lol.

    The entire game plan included a lot of specific stuff which led to him taking Tyson out. Mike didn’t faint from being held, he got KTFO.

    For starters, his team took advantage of Tyson’s tendency to square up with his feet even by game planning for Evander to basically put his left knee right under Tyson’s nuts, planted between his feet, to (a) take away the uppercut and (b) to gain leverage to push Mike back again and again. That’s how he physically manhandled Tyson.

    They knew Mike’s way of fighting relied on him planting his feet and propelling himself forward as he punched, so Evander repeatedly engaged and took it to Tyson to keep him more on the back foot. Tyson relied on chasing opponents who were on the back foot so Holy stayed on the front foot.

    They knew Tyson was a bully so Evander bullied him. He was relentless. Mostly he got off first. And when Tyson punched, Evander countered … never let Tyson seize the momentum.

    There’s plenty more technical stuff but it’s obviously far over your head.

    Sorry your guy lost. Twice.
     
  13. sauhund II

    sauhund II Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,494
    2,186
    Nov 8, 2008
    LOL,

    There’s plenty more technical stuff but it’s obviously far over your head.................a little more than a half dozen rounds in close to 4 years including a three year prison stint, naturally, you always get better in jail, mandatory for Top Athletes.
     
  14. McGrain

    McGrain Diamond Dog Staff Member

    111,936
    45,803
    Mar 21, 2007
    Untrue.

    This content is protected


    The big problem with this is that MIke co-oeprated with holding throughout his entire career. There was no time in his career where he didn't co-operate with holding, most especially when it came to holding one arm. He holds one arm almost every clinch. I'll do round one.

    12:22. First clinch. Mike misses with a left hook and wraps his arm around Holyfield initiating the clinch. You then se Holyfield's arm go behind Mike and hold. Mike initiated this clinch. He always did this when he missed with a left hook.

    12:34. Second clinch. Mike is holding Holyfield's left arm with his right arm. He always did this when he felt exposed inside. Mike's clinch. Holyfield pushes him off and punches.

    12:39. Third clinch. Clearly mutual.

    12:46. Fourth clinch. Mutual, but Holyfield throws two punches while Mike just holds.

    13:02. Fifth clinch. Holyfield initiates Mike immediately co-operates holding the back with his right hand.

    13:18. Sixth clinch. Holyfield initates. Mike immediatley co-operates.

    13:31. Seventh clinch. Holyfield initiates. Mike co-operates.

    13:45. Eighth clinch. Holyfield initiates.

    13:57. Ninth clinch. Holyfield initiates.

    14:05. Tenth clinch. Mike initiates with the hand round the back. Holyflied might be holding Mike's other arm but hard to say.

    14:25. Eleventh clinch. Mutual. Mike last to seperate.

    14:33. Twelfth. Difficult one. Holyfield dips into the clinch position, but Mike is the first to hold. Mutual, giving the benefit of the doubt to Mike.

    14.46. Thirteenth clinch. The reverse of the twelfth.

    14:53. Fourteenth clinch. Mike clearly grabs for Holyfield's left arm and holds it. A learned habit, a taught one.

    15:05. Fifteenth clinch. As above.

    Clearly, based upon the footage, the responsibility is shared. This idea that it's all Holyfield's fault, that is false. What I will say is that Mike was, as always, awful in the clinch. Passive, he allowed himself to be walked. Passive, he allowed Holyfield to position his head where he liked. Passively, he didn't punch. Note that Holyfield throughout the fight, often punched when Mike instigated the clinch. He refused to let him have his own way. Mike possibly never did this though I don't know the fight 100% well enough to say - certainly it was very rare, and much rarer than the reverse.
     
  15. NewChallenger

    NewChallenger Member Full Member

    344
    308
    Oct 17, 2020
    I have never stated that Mike was an infighter, he was not,he needed you to go backwards so he could load up, that is why he looked so damn akward when they got close, which is why Frazier knocks him out( Marvis was not in the same League as Joe). I know this probably is a bad example because it is post prison, but look at his fight with That Mathis or whatever his name was, that was akward as hell. Or I think Tubbs where it just looked real weird. If you watched Mike's fights, you constantly hear Kevin screaming at the top of his lungs "PUNCH OUT!" "PUNCH OUT!"

    I'll try to break down the clinches:

    12:22 – Evander is holding on for dear life here. Mike literally has to push him off as he is holding both his hands here. There is a headbutt here btw, I’m not gonna point it out every time,but I think it is interesting. Holyfield’s Clinch


    12:34 – I don’t really call this a clinch as it is an akward situation. Of both throwing punches and pushing off, if you want to say this is a clinch then fine.


    12:39 – This is what you are gonna see as a trend. Evander punches Mike (this was not a punch that landed of any significance) and then he holds on. He is the one that has his hand around Mike’s arm and head. Holyfield’s clinch


    12:46. Evander clinches here. It is an akward situation,but it is a clinch I’d say. Also Evander low blows Mike as mitch Halpern goes behind him. And it doesn’t really mean much because I have to question Mitch Halpern, but he even says “let go Evander”(he have also said let go man but the word ends with ‘der so I assume he said Evander). Holyfield Clinches


    Before we get to this next one, I want you to look at 12.58-13.00, if Mike really initiates nearly all these clinches or all of them are mutual as you suggest. Mike is getting hit A LOT here,why is he not clinching here? This is what I’m talking about and it is not helping your argument


    13:02. This is Evander again. Headbutt too. Holyfield clinches.



    13:18 Evander is the one that is Clinching here, he is diving into it too. Holyfield clinches


    13:31 – Mike landed a punch,and evander clinched, . Holyfield clinches.


    13:45. This is an akward situation again, yes evander grabbed his arm, but I don’t want to call this a clinch because it wasn’t to me.


    13:57. Evander gets hit with a right, and clinched holding onto his head. Holyfield clinches.


    14:05. This one is on Mike. Tyson Clinches


    Before we get to this next one, you will again see something that doesn’t help your argument. 14:11-14:21 Evander is beating the **** out of Mike here, and Mike just takes it. This is a perfect opportunity to clinch him, yet all he does is just stand there and take every punch to the head. How exactly is Mike the clincher here when he is getting beat up and he just stands there and takes it?


    14:25. Evander clinches after Mike lands a right, it was a weak punch as he held his hand out, but he did land and Evander IMMIDIATLY clinches. Holyfield clinches


    14:33. This is Mike’s fault, you literally see him wrap his arms around Evander. Tyson clinches


    14.46 – Mike Lands a punch, Evnader wraps his hands around his head. Holyfield Clinches.


    14:53. This I will say is Mike’s fault. Tyson Clinches


    15:05. Evander wraps his arm around Mike’s left arm. Holyfield clinches.



    So this is 10-3. Also it doesn’t help Evander’s case that Mike literally takes punches instead of clinching so there is that too isn’t it? Mike lands 1 punch and Evander holds. Evander unleashes 10 and Mike doesn’t. I actually wanna go and look at round 2 and 3 now. This is kind of fun.
     
    Overhand94 likes this.