**UK & Ireland All Time Light-Heavyweight Survey (poll closes 14th September**

Ken Buchanan is definitly top 5 P4P

 

Ahead of Fitz, Wilde, Kid Lewis, Kid Berg and Lennox Lewis? Not sure about that one. Definitely top ten though.

 

hers a rough one

1. Fitzsimmons
2. Wilde
3. Kid Berg
4. Kid Lewis
5. Buchanan
6. Lewis

 

Ken B nearly always gets overated IMHO. He gets into the top ATG 5 Brits and the top ATG 10 Lightweights and he shouldn't be in either (IMHO!!!).

 

When will Lennox get the praise he deserves :-(

Also, I agree with Dan - Welsh should be getting a top 5 spot.

 

I got banned too. And the link I got didn't even ****ing work until just after the precise moment when it ended.

 

I wouldn't have Buchanan ahead of Lewis.
Don't forget this involves Irish aswell, Jimmy McLarnin deserves a place in there somewhere(well definitely ahead of Buchanan imo).

I don't want it to seem like I'm running down Ken, he was a great fighter and Scotland's greatest ever but I think he falls a little short of the others on the list.

 

:-(

Kens a true ATG

Lennox is 6th

Welsh 7th although i have to research him more

Mclarnins American (or i class him as a yank)

 

How can you class McClarin as a yank but have Fitz as a Brit?

No way is Ken B above Lewis P4P, get those Scottish rose tinted specs off!!!

 

McLarnin was born in Ireland to two Irish parents and spent the first few years of his life in Ireland. His family then moved to Canada where he grew up......so em, how is he American ?

Lewis and Fitz are a lot less British than McLarnin is Irish.

 

I honestly think that i cant be arser writing a big explanation why but if you want to i will

Ill be honest i always thought he was born in America, shows me atsch

 

You can if you want, be warned though I'll rip it to shreds with my counter-argument....

 

Gaz your own when i get some time

 

bump

 

Finnegan was way,waayy better than Andries!