UNBEATEN? Collazo v. Hatton and Castillo v. Mayweather - did they both really lose?

I called Hatton-Collazo for Hatton by one point, and Mayweather-Castillo 1 a draw.

 

Hatton beat Collazo but Mayweather clearly lost. Mayweather has skipped and jumped his way through division avoiding the top fights. I don't know why the **** he would fight Delahoya who is actually a losing fighter lately. Means nothing, and he looked beatable in that fight also.
​

 

I don't feel Mayweather vs Castillo 1 is a fair judgment of Floyd as he was injured in the fight. If anything, it showed his heart in a critical situation as he gutted it out by fighting with 1 arm, controversial decision or not.

After the decision, he gave Castillo a rematch immediately, and won a non-controversial decision when completely healthy. I really think that makes it a wash in my opinion.

I didn't see Hatton jumping to fight Collazo again.

 

I had Castillo beating Mayweather by 3 points in their first fight, and Hatton beating Collazo by a point in their fight.

 

I think Callazo won more rounds even with the KD. He beat hatton as in a very close fight but it was clear Hatton shouldn't have gotten the nod.

In the Castillo fight I think Jose beat Floyd by the slimest of margins but it was a closer and tougher fight to call than Hatton vs Callozo IMO.

 

Oops, I accidentally voted that Mayweather-Castillo was a draw. I thought Castillo won.

 

I had Hatton up 7-5 against Collazo and Mayweather beating Castillo by a point i think. Both good close fights but no robbery either way

 

great thread decebal and nice poll :good

 

I'm glad to see that the majority of the people here see those 2 fights the way they truly were.

 

I watched the Hatton fight a month ago again and I scored it by 1 point for Hatton.

I have just watched the Mayweather fight and I scored it by 1 point for Castillo. I thought the Castillo Mayweather fight is a lot closer than how the HBO morons scored it, or how alot of the people here have scored it. The 12th gave it to Castillo on effective agression. Castillo by 114-113. The fact the judges scored it 115-111 twice and 116-111 once shows it was a a dodgy decision.atsch