UNBEATEN? Collazo v. Hatton and Castillo v. Mayweather - did they both really lose?

Castillo clearly won 6 rounds of the fight. The 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th, 11th and 12th. There can be no arguments on that.

Those three judges must have been well paid for that fight, very well paid for all three judges to give Castillo only 3 rounds.:deal

 

Great honest assesment here. Thanks for keeping out the BS even though you were rooting for the guy that you thought lost.

 

I tend to agree with the poll's results. Mayweather lost.

 

I felt Mayweather edged out the Castillo fight, but I have absolutely no problem giving it to Castillo. Easily the closest and most controversial fight of Mayweather's career.

I felt Hatton beat Collazo (114-113). It was a close fight and yet again, I wouldn't have a problem giving the nod to Collazo.

I believe both Mayweather and Hatton are Undefeated...but one of them wont be in 7 or 8 hours.

 

good thread. I had both Hatton winning in close fights.

 

hatton won

floyd drew, floyd was injured though it carries little importance

 

anyone having Hatton win but Mayweather lose is biased and has an agenda I cant see it any other way.

 

You had Collazo by one round yet you don't think it was that close? I guess in your mind it's only a robbery if someone's wining by half a point and doesnt get the nod right?