Unbeaten since 18 years old

How can someone be in the hall of fame without having fought in the USA? Surely, that's what REALLY matters, not a boxer's performances/opposition/talent/anything?

 

How long before someone bites???

 

It would have been much more impressive if he fought the top guys.

 

:good

 

OMG i can't believe you said that. Americans are so biased! Every single one of them is an idiot!

Not one american can actually see things objectively! Especially not Kellerman, Steward, and Lampley who all acknowledged that Calzaghe was a great fighter.

 

Valuev the giant Heavyweight had what 44-45 straight victories before he lost, does he deserve to be in the hall of fame too? Theres alot of fighters that can fight nobodys for 15 years and not lose, it's who you fight and beat that counts.

 

Of course. The HOF is in America so I agree.

 

There you have it: a straight admission from an American that they don't have a clue about boxing. Or anything, really.

 

Really? Where?

 

Who the hell cares if hes unbeaten since kindergarten...Hes fought alot of nobodies also

What matters now is that he owned that blubbermouth Hopkins!

Go Joe!!!

 

Sooooooo Byron Mitchell , Chris Eubank, Kessler, Jeff Lacy , Robin Reid, Sakio Bika, Ritchie Woodhall, Charles Brewer, Mario Veit were all nobodies..??

WTF... So Virgil Hill fights almost all of his life in Bismark ND..

Svenn Ottke , never leaves Germany.. and are both embraced as great fighters... And you question Josephs route into anyones list of ATG's..

Puleease................

 

There's at least one recent fighter in the Hall who never fought in the US (Khaosai Galaxy)

 

I haven't lost a professional boxing match since I was eighteen. Does that make me a hall-of-famer?

 

Uhhm... excuse me Mr. Pharoh, but you know that was bull ****. Of course as with any country you get your share of idiots, but heres one single American that can see objectively that Joe Calzaghe is A+++ fighter and it would be a crime that should incite world wide rioting if Joe isn't inducted into the hall of fame.

****er.