Very interesting Harry Greb article

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by bman100, Jan 31, 2011.


  1. bman100

    bman100 Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,795
    27
    Jan 6, 2010
    Dunno if anyone has read this or if its been posted before but I found it interesting so I'd thought I'd share. Very interesting Greb's thoughts on Fulton and his own thoughts on how hard he could punch.


    A Tale of Two Harrys


    Theirs was one of the great, enduring friendships in boxing history. One
    went onto great accomplishments in journalism; the other, to pugilistic
    immortality.

    Harry Keck first met Harry Greb in 1914, when Keck was with the
    Pittsburgh Post. Greb was in his second year as a pro. Greb had just
    returned from Philadelphia, where he had spent most of a year because
    promotional difficulties had led to a temporary suspension of boxing in
    Pittsburgh. From then on, Keck was with Greb throughout his career
    and conversed with him in Pittsburgh the night before the great
    middleweight died on an operating table in Atlantic City in October,
    1926.

    To the day he died, in April of 1956, Keck vehemently, jealously
    guarded the memory of Greb-about whom, Keck argued, more drivel
    had been written than about any other fighter.

    In 1964, Keck told me, "With each passing year, the Greb legend gets
    sillier and sillier. His alleged skirt-chasing, drinking, and apathy to training
    are canards that evidently will never die. Harry liked the companionship
    of both men and women, would take an occasional drink, and trained as
    hard as any fighter I ever knew."

    "Like so many of the old timers," Keck remembered, Greb often used
    one fight as preparation for the next. Don't forget-he fought so often that
    this training didn't have to be the elaborate month long ritual modern
    fighters make of it."

    Keck said most of the Greb stories were rehashes of the old balderdash.
    "The stealing goes on and on—and there's no end in sight," Keck would
    often remark "Next thing you know, some idiot will insist Greb had three
    arms."

    In July, 1925, Greb gave Mickey Walker a shot at the middleweight title
    he had won two years earlier from southpaw Johnny Wilson. Walker, at
    the time, was king of the welterweights. It was a thrilling, vicious fight,
    and Greb—seven years older, over the hill, and fighting with only one
    good eye—smacked Mickey around more than somewhat. Out of that
    fight came one of boxing's hoariest fairy tales: that the two men had a
    second brawl outside a New York nightclub. According to the fairy tale,
    Walker won that one. Mickey regaled many an afterdinner audience with
    that story—not a word of which, according to Keck, was
    true.

    "I was with Greb, from the time we left the Polo Grounds after Harry's
    brilliant victory, until we checked into a mid-town hotel," Keck recalled.
    "We didn't even see Walker. But if he's happy with the yarn, let him have
    it. There's such a thing as a man telling a story so often that he begins to
    believe it himself. Walker says it happened; I say it didn't."

    I once asked Keck if he thought Greb had ever known the meaning of
    fear.

    "I doubt it," he replied, "although I do know that Harry once turned
    down a chance to fight Fred Fulton. 'It's not that I'm afraid of Fulton, or
    that I don't think I can beat him,' Greb told me, 'but he's tall and has a
    fine jab and might bust me up pretty good before I could get to him. I
    have too many main events left in me to take the chance.' That was
    Greb, the fighter's fighter,a pro all the way. He wasn't bookish, neither
    was he stupid."

    "There weren't any such things as fan clubs in those days, Keck
    reminisced, "but had there been, Greb would have had a dandy if just his
    opponents been eligible for membership. And the president of the club
    would have Gene Tunney."

    Gene Tunably, who lost his only professional fight to him, remembered
    Greb as the greatest fighter—"in spots" —he had ever seen. Gene was a
    sincerely grieving pallbearer at Greb's funeral, and Tunney's esteem for
    his old opponent, far from waning, grew stronger with the passing of the
    years. They had fought five times, and only the first bout had Greb been
    victorious.

    Tommy Loughran once remarked that in his day the woods were full
    great fighters—"and on top of heap sat Harry Greb."

    Augie Ratner, a tough journeyman middleweight of Greb's era, went
    rounds with Harry—20 in New Orleans and 10 in Pittsburgh. When I
    visited Augie in Sanger, Calif., Augie said "Greb was a clean fighter with
    me." He said Greb was one of the three best ringmen he ever saw. Ted
    Kid Lewis and Benny Leonard were the other two.

    "Sure," Augie said, 'I've read those stones about Greb being the dirtiest
    fighter who ever lived. I didn't see him
    in all his fights, but those I did see were wild and woolly affairs—mostly
    because of Greb's hurricane style. I saw men much bigger than Harry
    deliberately foul him, and then all hell did break loose. Because Harry
    always gave as good as he took. Outside the ring, he was a personable
    guy with nice manners."

    Even Billy Roche, the famous oldtime referee and manager, in writing
    about Greb, repeated some of the myths about Harry.

    Wrote Roche:

    "Greb didn't confine his fistic operations to the prize ring. Once, speeding
    to a fight in an automobile with a bevy of female adrnirers, four stickup
    men blocked his road with a stalled car. Greb got out, unceremoniously
    and with dispatch, flattened the quartet of would-be robbers and
    continued on to keep his engagement. Cops picked up the unconscious
    victims and Greb had enough left to score a two-round KO.

    "Greb's real name was Berg. He changed it for 'business reasons.' "

    In actual fact, there is no evidence that Greb ever engaged in a street or
    barroom brawl. As Jimmy Slattery once wryly put it, "Who'd be crazy
    enough to take on Greb in a street or alley, with no referee?"

    And Greb's name was Greb. His father's first name was Pius, and
    Harry's was Edward Henry.

    Only one book about Greb has been written—by a man named James
    Fair, who, as Keck's ringside telegrapher, covered many of Harry's
    New York fights with him. He became enamored of Greb and wrote the
    book, "Give Him to the Angels," in 90 days. It turned out to be a
    chronicle of Greb's alleged sexual exploits, not a biography of a great
    fighter. When Greb's family threatened suit, the book was withdrawn
    from the market.

    They said he couldn't punch, couldn't box. What, then did Harry Greb
    have? Answer: he had blinding speed, a great rubbery pair of bouncy
    legs, a tremendous fighting heart. He started his fights at a fast pace and
    gradually accelerated it. None could keep up with him until he began to
    taper off in his last year or so. He once told Keck, -"I can hit as hard as
    any man my weight if I set myself to punch; but if I do that, I'll get hit in
    return." So he beat 'em with speed and endurance.

    Greb lost an eye in a fight with tough Kid Norfolk, who thumbed him.
    That was in 1921—and Greb fought for five more years with only one
    eye, beating most of the top fighters of his time. He never bewailed his
    fate; few persons knew about it .

    It has often been written that Greb died "under mysterious
    circumstances." Poppycock. One doctor said he died as a result of what
    we now call cardiac arrest; another said it was a cerebral hemmorhage
    that carried him off. In any event, he died of natural causes.

    Flaming courage in motion. Perpetual motion. That was Harry Greb.

    "A real nice guy...and probably the greatest fighter who ever lived. "

    That was Keck's epitaph for his friend.

    Harry Clevelin, Boxing Illsutrated August 1980
     
  2. D.T

    D.T Guest

    Greb = overrated.


    GOAT my ass.
     
  3. janitor

    janitor VIP Member Full Member

    71,220
    26,532
    Feb 15, 2006
    If Greb is over rated, then that is verry bad news for fighters since his time.

    Compared to prety much anybody after him, he is a giant among pygmies.
     
  4. DaveK

    DaveK Vicious & Malicious Full Member

    3,668
    35
    Mar 2, 2009
  5. heehoo

    heehoo TIMEXICAH! Full Member

    3,763
    13
    Feb 16, 2008
    Harry Greb is NOT overrated.
     
  6. janitor

    janitor VIP Member Full Member

    71,220
    26,532
    Feb 15, 2006
    It is quite simple really.

    If any fighter post 1945 wants to call themself the great then this is what they are up against

    This content is protected



    If your resume dosn't stack up against this guys then you are not the GOAT.

    Floyd Mayweather, I hope you are reading this!
     
  7. ron u.k.

    ron u.k. Boxing Addict banned

    4,920
    12
    Feb 14, 2006
    On what basis?
     
  8. Briscoe

    Briscoe Active Member Full Member

    941
    6
    Sep 19, 2009
    That article grounds Harry's myths to the corner with a dunce cap and really helps me level with how great of a fighter he was in the most real sense possible. Normally I'm hearing he was a horribly dirty whirlwind, with a nasty taste for females. Now I'm finally seeing the tough fleet-fisted fighter for who he actually was.
     
  9. jdempsey85

    jdempsey85 Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,487
    85
    Apr 23, 2011
    Very interesting indeed,anyway i was watching the mares v ponce fight last night in between rounds it cut away to floyds dressing room,john rawling commentating for boxnation mentioned pre fight rituals and harry grebs name came up.What were they??
     
  10. jdempsey85

    jdempsey85 Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,487
    85
    Apr 23, 2011
    ''Ive got too many main events left in me"sounds like something floyd m said about pacman.

    Was grebs ducking of fulton as blatant as floyd refusal to fight manny?
     
  11. nikrj

    nikrj Active Member Full Member

    1,449
    483
    Jul 23, 2011
    :lol: Agree. If Greb is overrated, Floyd Money Mayweather is a piece of ****...
     
  12. Seamus

    Seamus Proud Kulak Full Member

    59,397
    42,508
    Feb 11, 2005
    Well, considering that Greb was 160 to 170 pounds, 5 foot 8 and possessed a 71 inch reach, while conversely Fulton was almost 6 foot 7, 210 with an 85 inch reach... the answer is yes.
     
  13. burt bienstock

    burt bienstock Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    18,285
    388
    Jan 22, 2010
    S, how can a Greb who was truly a MW when he had to be ,by not tackling a Fred Fulton at 6ft5" and 210, by any stretch of the imagination called
    "ducking" ? To even equate Greb not fighting Fulton as parrallel with Floyd Mayweather avoiding Manny Paq, besmirches Harry Greb's astounding courage and legacy... To use an analogy would you or any sane person call
    MW Ray Robinson "ducking" a Rocky Marciano,a Joe Louis, by not tackling them ? Of course not...What did a Harry Greb have to gain ? No title by beating Fulton, and possible facial bruises that as Harry Keck wrote aeons ago, might disrupt the frenetic Greb's almost weekly bouts...Not "ducking"
    Harry was using common sense ...
     
  14. jdempsey85

    jdempsey85 Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,487
    85
    Apr 23, 2011
    @burt have u any idea what grebs pre fight rituals were?
     
  15. Seamus

    Seamus Proud Kulak Full Member

    59,397
    42,508
    Feb 11, 2005
    Burt, easy... that was sarcasm. I was highlighting the huge size disparity between the two fighters. My point was exactly that. Greb had no obligation to go fighting giants while he was a smallish middleweight.