Vic Darchinyan=HOF worthy?

Not so sure about that but he's a hell of fighter...

 

yeah he is one ko loss don't take that away.in fact if donaire keeps going on the same path he might not get in

 

Still needs more good wins to decide.

 

He has a shot the Donaire loss was best for him because it can help him go back to the gym and see what he really needs to work on. If his career keeps progressing and he beats quality names and dominates his division....that can get him in the hall for sure.

 

Perhaps, but he has more good wins then, say, Gatti. Hell, he has more good wins than Calzaghe.

 

Too early to tell. Take a guy like Donald Curry, by the time he destroyed fellow unbeaten welterweight belt holder Milton Mc Crory he seemed like the second coming of Ray Robinson. From there his fall was meteoric. No one would consider him a hall of famer at this point.
Then you have Billy Conn. Lost his first pro fight to an unknown, in fact lost a few in his first years as a Pittsburg club fighter. Now considered one of the greatest lightheavys ever.
A lot can happen in the course of a career. Vic has potential to be remembered forever as a great, but has more to do, and the time to do it. Wait and see.

 

I think Curry MIGHT make the hall but heh, I don't know what goes in the minds of the voters.

 

He had a late start with his career, so that might hold him back a little, but a few more good wins and he'll get in IMO

 

Couple more good wins and he should definetly get in

 

Yes...without a doubt.

 

Possibly. Immensely popular, got a good resume, multi weight champ...I could see it.

 

edit

 

Vic is like Valero, good but lots of flaws. not even funny.

 

I would say going back and getting revenge on a fighter of Donaire's caliber would be HOF worthy. Darch has defeated plenty of fighters but none of them were proven. Mijares was hyped up and duded out. Maldonado has been beaten by everyone, and Arce was a record builder if anything at this point. I think his biggest wins are against Tomas Rojas and Dmitry kirillov.