Vitali Klitschko, Wladimir Klitschko, Hollyfield, Lewis, Tyson

The fact that holyfield is perhaps the greatest cruiserweight of all time screws things up abit he gets overated on the all time heavyweights list but then underated on the general all time list.

 

lewis
wlad
tyson
holy
vitali

vitali loses to them all IMO. Lewis could lose to any of them, but should be favourite.

Wlad is number 2. this is H2H, not who's achieved what.

I think he beats vitlay and holy, loses to Lewis, and is 50 50 with Tyson.

Wlad Tyson are tied basically.

Holy beats Tyson only on this list for sure IMO, would be even money with vitlay. Vitlays best chance for a win.

 

Lewis won the first fight and the second fight on my cards. Lewis was clearly superior to Holyfield in every way. You are the one with the revisionist use of history, if you are trying to tell me that Holyfield was even competitive with Lewis. The only dangerous thing about him is his use of the headbutt.

The second fight was only close because Lewis was not as motivated, and he did not use he jab like he should have done letting the slow Holyfield get inside.

 

agreed.pfp he's the best here.
not "perhaps" the best ever cruiser btw

 

1 win 1 draw against lewis , are you judging him on one fight ?

 

I don't agree that holyfield was the better offensive fighter when lewis went for it he put people away quite often in a brutal way rather than holyfield who wore them down.

 

Sorry, but you can't make up a fighter's record according to how much you like him. Head to head Lewis came out top, there is never too much dispute over that. That's without mentioning the crooked judging in the first fight.

 

Lewis
Holyfield
Tyson
........then a drop as far as victoria falls....then
Wladimir
Vitali

 

magic mushrooms i suspect

 

I did actualy say i was tempted to put Lewis first, but my heart wouldent let me

 

first man to put mercer down ?

4 times champ.


but i suppose now his other draw against ruiz will get slated.

 

There could always be some debate over the the order of the top 3, but I think the idea of this thread was to to give the impression that the Klitschkos made it to some kind of shortlist.

Vitali's only claim to fame is losing in his biggest fights and Wlad is only highly regarded for what he might go on to achieve. If this was a list of heavyweights who achieved the most, then it would have to be a very long list before we saw the Klitschkos on it.