The first one by far for me. Round nine alone is worth the price of admission. Third fight was good too, but nothing like the first.
"I" by a long way, then "III". "II" wasn't as good. Quite one-sided because Gatti used his boxing skills rather than brawling.
That's my take on it too. The first fight swung one way and then the next, over and over, in the most dramatic fashion. I lent my copy of the fight out a few weeks ago and just got it back last night so I might give it another viewing after the bells.
1st one obviously. The 2nd was too one sided although Gatti looked good, 3rd was entertaining but even in the hard parts Gatti was in control.
The first one by miles. The rematch was alright but one-sided. The 3rd fight was good, but the 1st fight was great.