Was Johnson regarded as a better infighter or outfighter in his own time?

Yeah, if people were claiming victory for Machen it can only be explained by his unpopularity and the low blows he landed in the fight. By card:


Round 1: 10-9 Machen
True to his pre-fight bluster, Machen didn't seem scared at all and landed good punches.

Round 2: 10-9 Machen
Machen was able to slip behind Liston at one point and land a good combo on the future champ as he turned out of the ropes. He laid the blueprint in these first two rounds.

Round 3: 10-9 Liston
Liston turns the tide with hard punches to the body and head, but he has actually put the really heavy, swinging artillary to bed for the most part at this point, which was the right thing to do I think, and a good adjustment. Machen gets on his bike a bit for the first time.

Round 4: 10-9 Liston
"The winner of this one is thoroughly deserving of a title shot." Liston establishes his jab and Machen looks worried for the first time, continually moving rather than trying to tempt Sonny in for the counter. Ships a good one-two in this round. Liston declining to clinch.

Round 5: 10-9 Liston
Liston is trying to get across the heavy artillary again. He had some success with the lead right to the body but less with the left upstairs. Liston is wary of getting countered, but Machen scores a beautiful counter left and bulls Liston back.

Round 6: 9-9 Liston is docked a point for a low blow.
This is a really close round with Machen scoring with lead left hooks and Machen scoring with the right, Liston probably wins it in the last minute with the left, but a tied round is also fair. Liston hits Machen very low at the end of the round and he is furious, the ref takes a way a point.

Round 7: 10-10
They fight evenly again. Things have been bad-tempered at close quarters through the last two rounds. Both land good lefts.

Round 8: 10-9 Liston
Machen has some trouble in this round and begins to fight out of a crouch with which Liston has some trouble, but the big man is able to take advantage when Machen slips on what I think was water and lands his first uppercut of the fight! Machen really took that shot away from him, with good hyperactive movement, careful placement in clinches and good balance (never tilting in or to the side when punching). He was also careful not to remain stationary when crouching. Great skills. Liston shows his own though, landing the best combo of the fight ending in a clubbing right hand, thrown curved and with beautiful accuracy. He also scores with body blows on the belt line - the referee lets them go, but I thought they were debatable.

Round 9: 10-9 Liston
Liston is bringing pressure, bulling and throwing more punches. Machen is mobile throwing out jabs whilst on the move, but Liston does well to slip.

Round 10: 10-9 Liston
Liston returns to the jab as Machen stays on his bike. Machen lands his best punch of the fight, a left hook, but he is being bullied for the first time, and the size discrepancy is suddenly obvious.

Round 11: 9-8 Machen - the referee takes away TWO points for a low blow
Liston is frustrated and looking for the KO, lashing out at anything, really pouring it on. Machen shows great balance and awareness to keep himself out of the way of the uppercut. Machen hits on the break and Liston tries to get at Machen through the referee who looks a bit grumpy. Machen ships a really low uppercut and the referee gives him a minute to recover. Machen seems furious and shows great heart. They continue fighting after the bell.

Round 12: 10-10
Machen leading with hooks, Liston does good work to the body.

TOTALS: 115-112, Liston



Two of the three officals scored it wider.

 

Most excellent.

 

I didn't think McVey was a swarmer. You reckon he was?

 

Cool.

 

To me, a swarmer brings fast and consistent aggressive pressure. McVey looks like a stalker to me, but like Janitor, i'd prefer box-puncher to swarmer. But maybe we just use swarmer as a descriptive word in different ways.