Were there any "robberies" in history in which you scored for the actual winner?

Depends, are we talking ESB robberies or real robberies.

If we are talking ESB robberies, I had Taylor edging Winky.

 

i had forbes wining by two on that one

 

There are a couple people on this very site that "claim" they scored Chavez over Whitaker....one even said he had Ramirez over Whitaker as well.....

 

Jack Presscot scored Trinidad over De La Hoya

 

Mine would cause too much of a firestorm so I'm going to refrain from this one.

 

Tell us:good

 

I had Forrest/Quartey a draw

I also scored, Taylor/Winky for Taylor

 

Even though I didn't watch the fight I think Leonard vs. Hagler will brought up a few times.

The only one I have is Mayweather vs. De La Hoya. Some people were saying Oscar got robbed. It was a clear fight for Mayweather, Mayweathe countered all night long and the only reason people scored the fight for De La Hoya was because it LOOKED like he landed some punches on the ropes.

I think I scored it 116-112 for Mayweather, but that was being very generous to De La Hoya.

 

Not going to do it cuz the moment somebody wants to question my credibility they'll refer back to this thread by saying something like "aren't u the guy who scored the ______ fight for ______?"

No thanks.

I will say, on a smaller level, that I didn't think Forrest/Quartey was the robbery everyone thought it was.

 

I had Chavez-Whitaker a draw!

Trinidad two or three points over DLH!

DLH over Whitaker 117-112!

 

May I ask which 7 rounds you gave to Trinidad?

 

I hated Mayweather when he fought Castillo the first time, and badly wanted him to lose. I've watched that fight a few times and have narrowly scored it for Mayweather every time.

I had Peter narrowly winning the first fight with Toney.

Forrest over Quartey.

Taylor over Wink.

I'm sure there are many more, that I can't think of at the moment.

 

I'm not about to rewatch the fight and rescore it to give you wish rounds.....I did'nt see where DLH was clearly outboxing Trinidad through the first 9 rounds as alot of people like to point out.
DLH did to much running and too much postering even through the first 9 for me to call that effective boxing.

The way I remember it, I had DLH ahead by a point after 8 or 9 rounds, and I wound up giving Trinidad the remainder of the rounds.

 

I had DLH beating Quartey. Never understood the " robbery " backlash to that one.