What are your thoughts on UK boxing viewers ATG Top 10?

Calzaghe too low.

 

How the frigg is Jones Jr above Super Joe when Joe twatted him in a one sided beating? :-(

 

wow!! where's tarver and jermain taylor on this list? they had better wins vs jones and bhop. if there's was ever a reason not to take british boxing fans (as a whole) seriously, it's this poll. at least they understand jones was greater than calzaghe. this list is just embarrassing.

 

Don't be absurd.

Tarver's wins over Jones was due to Jones glass jaw. Nobody has given him a boxing lesson the likes of which Super Joe dished out.

 

Not surprised at all they think Calzaghe is a top 10 ATG when he isn't even top 100. Have you seen some of the british posters on here?

They are hideously deluded.

This poll really comes as no shock.

 

Where is Kell Brook?

 

That's the most superhumanly dumb GOAT list I've ever seen.

 

honestly, i wouldn't put him in my top 200 all-time. there's over 200 fighters in the hall of fame and he's one of the worst.

 

LOL at Mayweather and Calzaghe that high. Tyson too.

Actually the list is just terrible, but fan polls usually are.

 

yes, it was incredible. a performance fitting of putting him in the top 10 greatest fighters ever. (except for the part where jones put him on his ass)

 

Please name the 200 in front of Calzaghe on your list

 

1. Ali
2. Robinson
3. Mayweather Jr.
4. Leonard
5. Marciano
6. Tyson
7. Louis
8. Jones Jr.
9. Duran
10. Calzaghe

Calzaghe is just beyond ?. Jones JR, Tyson and Floyd should definitely not be in the top 10 either. I don't know why Louis is below Marciano (and Tyson for that matter).

 

just compare him to the other fighters in the hall and tell me which ones you think joe is greater than. he fought in an era where there were 18 divisions with 4 "title holders" in each class. he held one of those belts for a decade and fought a bunch of C level fighters in that run. his best wins were over jeff lacy, mikkel kessler, a one-month shy of 40 roy jones and a 43 year old hopkins.

that resume is surpassed by about everyone else in the hall.