1. trinidad 2. tarver 3. de la hoya 4. pascal rematch sorry, had to put 4 since he became the oldest world champion when he defeated pascal. beating foremans record
I tend to look at what fighters have done at a weight. I think at MW it was possibly K Holmes, but he has some better wins at LHW. Tarver is the win that I would possibly call his best win. Tarver Wright Pavlik Reading your post again stating legacy/resume/atg standing Legacy, maybe the Tarver win for his LHW win going up 2 weights or the Cloud win for oldest fighter to win a world title Resume, tough one as I cant recall Hopkins beating a big top fighter at a weight where they havent been fighters coming up in weight, but I would possibly go for Tarver again as Tarver was the LHW champ and had avenged his loss to Johnson and had beaten Jones ATG standing, tough one again but I think that may just be an accumulation of an outstanding career with several good wins and what he has done since being a LHW to go with his MW reign
Pavlik win gets criminally underrated. Guy only lost to Martinez and Hopkins I believe. He smashed Taylor (who beat Bhop twice) twice then Hopkins came in and destroyed Pavlik. I would say: 1) Tarver 2) Pavlik 3) Trinidad
