What fighter has the chance of taking fighter of the year from Manny?

Boom_Boom · Nov 14, 2010

Nonito Smoak said: ↑

As of right this instant, it is without a doubt Fernando Montiel.

If Sergio can defeat Williams, it would obviously be him.

And if Pascal defeats Hopkins and Sergio does not defeat Williams, it'd be between Pascal and Montiel.

If Wladimir defeats Chisora in December, I'd liken him as the next option.

Mayweather, the #2 P4P, according to The Ring, dominating the #3 P4P would make him my next choice. Hasn't been since Dempsey-era a fighter took FOTY with one win, but this year is quite weak.

Let's get real, Joshua Clottey win is on the level of, at the very best, Wladimir's win over Eddie Chambers. And Wladimir's win over Samuel Peter is of higher relevance than... unranked and nowhere close to being ranked Antonio Margarito. I'm stunned people'd feel Pacquiao even has a remote chance, let alone being considered one of the favorites.
Click to expand...

No

He's not getting it, Montiel needed Donaire to get FOTY.

and @ your crackhead giving mayweather a mention

D50 · Nov 14, 2010

Nonito Smoak said: ↑

As of right this instant, it is without a doubt Fernando Montiel.

If Sergio can defeat Williams, it would obviously be him.

And if Pascal defeats Hopkins and Sergio does not defeat Williams, it'd be between Pascal and Montiel.

If Wladimir defeats Chisora in December, I'd liken him as the next option.

Mayweather, the #2 P4P, according to The Ring, dominating the #3 P4P would make him my next choice. Hasn't been since Dempsey-era a fighter took FOTY with one win, but this year is quite weak.

Let's get real, Joshua Clottey win is on the level of, at the very best, Wladimir's win over Eddie Chambers. And Wladimir's win over Samuel Peter is of higher relevance than... unranked and nowhere close to being ranked Antonio Margarito. I'm stunned people'd feel Pacquiao even has a remote chance, let alone being considered one of the favorites.
Click to expand...

Hype machines and viewer perception often win out over scientific analysis.

Dracon · Nov 15, 2010

Round1gymDC said: ↑

Let's face it as of right now Manny is the fighter of the year even though it was fake in October it's real now.

These are the list of fighters I think my have a chance based on their good performances earlier this year.

Sergio Martinez, Juan Marquez, Andre Ward, and Khan. All these guys would have to dominate, but I want you to answer how bad would they have to beat their opponent to Match Pac's 2010 campaign?
Click to expand...

:huhWhy the **** is Ward even there? That's a terrible choice. I guess you COULD have made a case for him last year (though a very weak one), but what has he done in 2010? Beat up the great Allan Green who was knocked out cold by Johnson in his next fight?

Even if he kills the whole Bika family in the ring in less than 1 round in his next bout, he doesn't deserve a mention.atsch

bandido · Nov 15, 2010

Martinez if he convincingly wins against williams. Montiel should be in the poll.

Log in or Sign up

What fighter has the chance of taking fighter of the year from Manny?

Boom_Boom R.I.P Boxing 6/9/12 Full Member

D50 Active Member Full Member

Dracon Frédéric Bastiat Full Member

bandido The Black Bandit Full Member

Log in or Sign up

Forums

What fighter has the chance of taking fighter of the year from Manny?

Boom_Boom R.I.P Boxing 6/9/12 Full Member

D50 Active Member Full Member

Dracon Frédéric Bastiat Full Member

bandido The Black Bandit Full Member