What is your brand new P4P List?

the ranking of ward in this thread is nothing short of disgracefull, infact the american blinkered bias absoloutely stinks.

this is a man who has 1 notable victory on his entire resume against kessler. tell me, where were you ranking kessler on you p4p lists before ward beat him? i bet the majority of you didn't even have kessler in your top 15.

oh well, you ****ers will learn the hard way, just like you did with chad dawson, kelly pavlik, jermain taylor, jeff lacey etc etc

 

I'm not even American.

 

Donaire at 2 is not right.

 

Wig's P4P list:

1 Mayweather
2 Pacquiao
3 Martinez
4 JM Marquez
5 Froch
6 Juanma Lopez
7 Bradley
8 Cotto
9 Donaire
10 W Klitschko


A couple of points:
- Anyone with Andre Ward anywhere near their P4P top 10 should be sentenced to death row for gross oxygen larceny
- You either have Mayweather at #1 or not on the list at all

 

My Top 5

1.Pac
2.May(if he's still counted as active)
3.Marquez
4.Martinez(can be switched with Donaire)
5.Donaire

Top 6 to 10

6. Won
7. Bradley
8. Segura
9. Hopkins
10. Ward

 

No but your list is an utter disgrace.:tired

 

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Sergio Martinez
4. Nonito Donaire
5. Juan Manuel Marquez
6. Wladimir Klitschko
7. Vitaly Klitschko
8. Juan Manuel Lopez
9. Bute
10. Amir Khan

Sorry I cant find a "slick black fighter" to put in there other than floyd...Most of them are hypejobs and no heart anyway...They quit like Dela Hoya...LOL

 

why didn't you just write 1 to 10 :huh

 

1. Manny paquiao
2. Sergio martinez
3. Nonito donaire
4. Floyd mayweather
5. Juan manuel marquez
6. Juan manuel lopez
7. Tim bradley
8. Miguel cotto
9. Bernard hopkins
10. Paul williams

 

Good point.

Maybe he's trying to separate the 'elite' from the rest of them.

 

The top 5 are on a level of their own, plus i was only planning on posting my top 5 :rasta

 

pac
martinez
donaire
wlad
jmm

 

:deal

 

I have him #3 due to only one fight in a year. If he doesnt fight until may, he will be gone.

1. Pac
2. Martinez
3. Floyd
4. Wladimir
5. Donaire
6. JMM

I aint sure about 7-10. I would only mention: Cotto, Adamek, Ward, Froch, Bute, Hopkins, Montiel, Bradley, Khan, Gamboa, Lopez, Berto, Pascal. It would be top20 (7-20 in no order)

 

Based off of recent wins and ability and skill
1. Pacquiao
(Ability wise he's number 2, but mixed with recent wins and he's number 1)
2. Mayweather
(Best fighter on the list, but he got moved down AFTER the Pac/Margarito fight. Coming off of wins over the number 3 and 2 p4p fighters in the world)
3. Martinez
(I would put Donaire here, but I rate a KO over Williams over Montiel and he has that win over Pavlik also)
4. Donaire
(Great ability and great performance, but I told you why I rated him here)
5. Marquez
(He's still good despite him aging)
6. Lopez
(Win over Marquez solidified this spot)
7. Wladimir
(I don't like putting heavyweights, especially big ones here, but he's earned it)
8. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
(Very skilled)
9. Bradley
(Beat the number 3 guy in the division and has been on top of the division for years)
10. B Hop
(Dawson was rated very high on this list and Pascal beat him and Bernard beat him. Hasn't loss since SD to Calzaghe)