I scored it a loooooong time ago, and I had Pac winning the first, and JMM winning the second. Both by just a mere point or two. It’s hard for me to say who deserved the wins the most, because they both built strong cases for themselves. JMM outboxed him more, whilst Pac inflicted the most damage (those four knockdowns count for a lot!). One thing that I do know for certain, though, is that JMM was not robbed. You can’t claim such a thing in close fights like that. (Sorry, not quite the definitive answer you were looking for)
Don't have my scorecard for the first fight, but I had Pac winning it closely. Also had him winning the rematch by a single point, though I wouldn't argue with the same score for Marquez. Here's my scorecard for the rematch... Round 01 - 10-9 Pacquiao Round 02 - 10-9 Marquez Round 03 - 10-8 Pacquiao Round 04 - 10-9 Pacquaio Round 05 - 10-9 Marquez Round 06 - 10-9 Marquez Round 07 - 10-9 Pacquaio Round 08 - 10-9 Marquez Round 09 - 10-9 Pacquaio Round 10 - 10-9 Pacquiao Round 11 - 10-9 Marquez Round 12 - 10-9 Marquez 114-113 Pacquaio
Marquez won the second for sure. The first deserves a draw, but I don't remember Pac winning much rounds after the 2nd round in the first fight
Never tried to score the first fight but I know the 2nd fight I had it 114-113, knockdown won it for Pac
First one is 50-50 depend on how you view the first round 10-6 or 10-7 second one JMM 100% without a shadow of a doubt won I also feel that he won the first one but it is debatable
This. I stopped actively scoring the first one figuring Pac only needed to win a couple of rounds to win the decision. In the second, I had it even outside of the knockdown.
113-112 Pac (7 rounds to 5 for JMM, the 3 knockdowns giving Pac the one point edge). 114-113 Pac (6 rounds a piece, the 4th round knockdown splitting the difference).
Pac won both by one or two points due to the knockdowns, without them he would have lost both I think.
