Morales beats Gavin, even now. Erik needs to go out on this high and retire. As far as I am concerned, he beat Maidana last night! :rasta
I didn't see the fight, but if Morales brought it the way everyone is saying he did than the answer to the question is 'all of the above'. If he went down to the wire with Maidana he's a viable contender at 140.
It would be a great time to retire. He had nothing to prove before fighting Maidana and after a performance like that he can go out on an even higher note than if he would've retired before last night.