What was worse? The headbutts or the cheap shot combo?

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by CarlesX7, Sep 19, 2011.


  1. Chris85

    Chris85 Boxing Addict Full Member

    3,140
    1
    May 6, 2009
    I didnt see the whole fight, from what I saw... the head butts were done on the fight, the cheap shots were done while the guy was saying sorry.

    Ill say the cheap shots.
     
  2. horst

    horst Guest

    The other instances were not in the same league as that insane final attempt. The others were just standard butts on the inside that we see in many fights. Not that they're acceptable, they're not, they're still cheating, but let's not pretend that all of the headbutts were the same, they weren't. Before that final moment of madness, Ortiz's use of the head wasn't any worse than Floyd's use of the elbow/forearm in pretty much every fight he ever has. Standard rough-house tactics. The final headbutt attempt for Ortiz was just a pure moment of madness, the young man was desperate and stupid because the realization had set in that he was in the ring with a superior fighter who was going to punish him in the fight. That's my view on it anyway, not fussed if you agree or disagree man.
     
  3. victor879

    victor879 Boxing Junkie Full Member

    11,017
    42
    Dec 1, 2007
    That's just bull**** and you know it. He tried the EXACT same thing. He was springing with his legs to hit Mayweather with his head. Same technique on FOUR SEPARATE OCCASIONS. The only difference on the last one was he was so desperate to hit him with the head again, he left his feet.

    Blatant intentional headbutts are not any worse than Floyd's elbow/forearm that isn't even a ****ing foul? You're nuts.

    I know you're one of the more "objective *******s" (if there is such a thing) but seriously brother, Ortiz was dirty as hell. One of the ugliest displays of dirty boxing I have seen in quite some time, and frankly, I never want to see him fight again.

    And I can watch some cagey rough-house bouts as you said... but what Ortiz was doing is not that.
     
  4. horst

    horst Guest

    I disagree. You yourself concede the last one was different, and this is my p-o-v. Ortiz was not doing anything differently from guys like Bradley or B-Hop or Ward do, until he lost it and went for a full lunging headbutt to the face. For what it's worth, the way Floyd uses his elbow/forearm is ALWAYS a foul, it's just that for some bizarre reason refs don't call it very often. No way in hell are you permitted by the rules to plant your forearm on someone's neck and force his head back! It's the exact same scenario as Bradley getting away with constant headbutts.

    But as I say, I doubt we are going to convince one another. I also think Ortiz's behaviour was disgraceful, but for me the final headbutt was a different animal entirely from his use of the head throughout. I think Cortez would agree with me, considering his reaction to the final butt as opposed to the earlier uses.
     
  5. SRCP

    SRCP Well-Known Member Full Member

    1,530
    0
    Jul 21, 2007
    Which ever came first is worse of course. The one in retaliation can't possibly be as bad. Unless Floyd had hit him with a bat or something. Headbutts can be very dangerous. I think Floyd should have hit him with that first shot and that's it though. Why ruin the fight like? He doesn't give a **** about the fans, honestly.
     
  6. CarlesX7

    CarlesX7 Shit got real! Full Member

    13,209
    291
    Sep 23, 2008
    Have you read my posts in this thread or any other thread about this subject? Where the hell did I say that Mayweather's actions are worthy of praise, and where the hell did I claim that his punches weren't premeditated? Those are two fouls right there.

    Why should someone with a different opinion than yours 'have an agenda' while you're the objective one by default? If you want to discuss be prepared to do it and give your thoughts which are welcomed, don't try to discredit the other guy's view on the subject with arrogant remarks.

    And because I watched the fight live, and because I've watched the sequences we're discussing here multiple times, I have a certain view-point on the subject, one that I've explained a dozen times. What's all this about pre-programmed ****. I have my opinion, you have yours, and we're talking.

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Essentially I don't think we're disagreeing here. You're saying it was premaditated, and I'm saying it definitely was premaditated. Floyd calculated his actions, like he always does and what he did was absolutely wrong, although it was retaliation as he was provoked earlier. BUT, my point is that Mayweather never hugged him and he never looked like he was ok with what happened, and was in a fighting stance the moment they came together, after Cortez said 'lets go'.

    Ortiz on the other hand was apologetic and unprepared during ALL this time. It's obvious that his mind was stuck at what he did and he felt guilty and wanted to apologize, but the fact that he wasn't prepapared at any time wasn't a result of Mayweather's behaviour, but because of the fact that he was only thinking 'wtf what did I do, sorry'.

    And you wanted video evidence, I'm giving you video evidence.

    As they approach each other: Ortiz is going for the hug, while Mayweather has his hands up, already prepared to resume fighting at any time.

    This content is protected



    After Ortiz hugs him and they begin backing away from each other: Ortiz' hands start to fall all the way down, Mayweather is in the same stance he was before Ortiz hugged him, in a fighting stance.

    This content is protected



    Also, some people mentioned the body language and stuff. Here's Mayweather's look as he's approaching Ortiz after Cortez said 'lets go'. To me it's a 'yea yea, whatever punk, lets do this'.

    This content is protected



    Ortiz, on the other hand looks like 'ohh man my bad, I'm sorry'

    This content is protected
     
  7. CarlesX7

    CarlesX7 Shit got real! Full Member

    13,209
    291
    Sep 23, 2008
    In short: I agree that what Mayweather did was calculated, cruel, premaditated and wrong. This is obvious.

    But I disagree that Ortiz was unprepared because of Mayweather's actions. He was unprepared because his mind was stuck elsewhere, and because he's inexperienced. Oh, and of course because Cortez ****ed it up, he added to the confusion.
     
  8. horst

    horst Guest

    Apologies if I was a little off there, just very tired of people hailing a suckerpunch KO as an act of virtue and heroism.

    Going by video evidence, I still have no idea where you are coming from tbh. :nut

    Mayweather walks over with his hands down as if to accept a reconciliation, allows Ortiz to gesture, and with Ortiz still in the moment and unprepared, he suckerpunches him.

    Absolutely clear-cut, clear as crystal, and as I keep saying, I genuinely do not believe that Floyd himself would deny that he purposefully deceived Ortiz in order to maximise the shock value, punch impact, and viciousness of his retaliation.

    I think you're a good poster, but I have absolutely no idea where you're coming from here. I cannot understand how you interpret the video evidence in this way. If Floyd had walked over with his hands up, or had the apology from Ortiz then moved back to affect a fighting stance, then I'd see your point. But there was clear deceit in the way he had his hands down allowing Ortiz to gesture, and then moved immediately into a strike.

    I fear we are too far apart on this one to reach any common ground amigo. :-(
     
  9. millertime1367

    millertime1367 Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,777
    1
    Sep 11, 2008
    i wonder what everyone would be saying if Ortiz had been pulling his hands up as they backed away? The result could have been the exact same...Ortiz just would have looked like he was 'ready'...he mind effed himself...after the kiss, he was no longer viscous nor his mind in the fight
     
  10. millertime1367

    millertime1367 Well-Known Member Full Member

    2,777
    1
    Sep 11, 2008
    also, why is it that we can all see Floyd's intentions in his facial expressions and Ortiz could not? Its pretty obvious Ortiz didn't see them anyway....with that said, its just as possible that Floyd didn't see Ortiz wasn't ready..........so, as bad as the ko looked...there may be no moral blame at all.....
     
  11. CarlesX7

    CarlesX7 Shit got real! Full Member

    13,209
    291
    Sep 23, 2008
    No worries. It's just that I am not one of those who are hailing a suckerpunch KO as an act of virtue and heroism, that's why I read your response and I went 'whoaa' :lol:

    But the third picture I uploaded is right at the time when Floyd approaches Ortiz. You keep saying that Mayweather walks over with his hands down, in this picture you see him holding his hands down? :think

    This content is protected



    His hands are not down, mate. And right after this moment, he completely lifts them up, as you see in the other pictures.
     
  12. CarlesX7

    CarlesX7 Shit got real! Full Member

    13,209
    291
    Sep 23, 2008
    That's the whole point, imo. Ortiz' mind was gone after the headbutt, he wasn't there. That's why he didn't get that Mayweather was still angry as ****, and that's why he never heard Cortez say 'lets go', and that's why he never made any attempt to defend himself. Not because Mayweather tricked the poor kid. Because the kid ****ed up earlier, he knew it, and was feeling very guilty and confused. And because Cortez is a bum and didn't make things crystal clear as he brought them back together to fight.

    Now, of course Mayweather had his mind made up to punch right after they came together. Absolutely. He will be dirty in the ring, he has done it (worse) in the past, plus he's a vet and he always knows what he's doing. What I'm saying is that Ortiz brought all that to himself, by initiating it.
     
  13. Whipdatass

    Whipdatass Boxing Junkie banned

    9,353
    2
    Aug 18, 2011
    I'm glad you made the votes public.
     
  14. CarlesX7

    CarlesX7 Shit got real! Full Member

    13,209
    291
    Sep 23, 2008
    I always do.
     
  15. Whipdatass

    Whipdatass Boxing Junkie banned

    9,353
    2
    Aug 18, 2011
    One thing that these trolls fail to do is acknowledge the butt. Every last troll ignores this. All they talk about is what Floyd did. Trolls don't feel Floyds pain. They think they constantly **** Floyds fans off with their perversive opinions. They truly don't recognize how dangerous Ortiz's butt was. Had Floyd butted Ortiz, and got ko'd, we would be talking about the butt 24/7, and they'd be laughing their ass off and legitimizing Ortiz's ko win.