What would do more for Calzaghe's CV?

Depends entirely what Dawson did after.

His resume now is not nearly good enough to stand up to a couple of defeats.

 

A clearer win over Hop would be better, but he wouldnt get credit. It would be a 44 year old Hop.

Dawson by default

 

IMO, a clear win over Hopkins because to me the first fight only proved that B-Hop is a significantly more skilled operator, but a win over Dawson would greatly enhance his legacy too.

 

So you wouldn't just attribute any greater margin of victory to Hopkins' age and therefore fail to give Calzaghe any additional credit at all?

 

Dawson. Wouldnt get any cred for beatin Hop.

 

"A clear/clearer win over Bernard Hopkins. "

Joe has beaten him. Two judges gave him 9 and 8 of the rounds. He doesn't need a "clearer" victory. Dawson has more chance in fighting Joe. Bernard has 0% chance.

 

Whatchoo talking about Willis? Between the two of them, Calzaghe and Dawson have cleared out the division (other than Erdei). Wins over Adamek, Tarver and Johnson is a much stronger resume than what Pavlik had when he challenged Hopkins, for instance (and frankly, there's a pretty decent argument that it's stronger than Hopkins' recent resume, where he had an equally dominant win over one of the same guys, and his two other good wins were against middleweights who had to move up to 170 to fight him).

 

bah - joe won by a very small margin, but he clearly won. no one really contends that.

 

IMO the first fight showed that Hopkins was more skilled. If Calzaghe fought him again but this time penetrated his defence, landed clean punches, and won convincingly then he will have demonstrated his skills can compare.

 

Hops spoiling tactics made it a **** fight, nobody wants to see it again, even if Joe wins a UD next time - which he almost certainly would. Nobody would enjoy it.:verysad

 

Fight the young guy and grab a belt.

 

neither, there will always be some young buck that hes ducking.

i tell you what would be better, sounds silly, but a defeat. If he got defeated by say b-pop, and came back and beat him after, he would earn **** loads more credit imo. Everyone who joe will fight or has fight will always have a tag to them, whether its that there shot, or just overated, Joes opponents will always be labelled

 

Too late. He should have fought better competition ages ago...