what would you think about a prime hatton vs prime kastidis fight at 140

Would be a good match-up. But a prime Hatton who would be fighting in his very own perfect weight class, would be a little too much for Katsidis who of course would be competing higher than his desired 135 zone.

It's much more reasonable to ask for this fight to take place now. Hatton is no longer in his prime, which would level things out at 140.

But prime Hatton would definately win at 140.

 

Yeah and asking Hatton to come to 135 is something too much I guess

 

Looking at the state he's been in the past year I think 140 is asking a lot.

 

I saw him banging a bag at 180 I guess...

I was like.. damn, that will never come off

 

It would be exciting but a PRime Hatton was a tier above Katsidis as far as all around fighters. I though Diaz beat Katsidis pretty easy, Katsidis would make it real entertaining but Hatton would stop him in 8 or 9 rounds.

 

Look at the state of him:

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pxGwrFLF3ww[/ame]

 

Prime for prime, Hatton would have kicked the **** out of Katsidis. Bigger, stronger, more of a bully, better boxer. Pretty clearly a class above. Right now though, who knows. Hatton's not what he once was, and after this latest balloon in weight, I suspect he will have lost more than just punch resistance.

 

Hatton by KO in an entertaining fight. Hattons clearly the better and bigger fighter.

 

I like Kat, but prime Hatton stops him in a one sided fight. Two different classes of fighter.

 

Would of been a quality scrap that.. Prime hatton edges it!

 

the 05' super fit and super confident version of Hatton would of smashed Kat to bits by the mid rounds.

 

in fact i think Hatton should of rode the crest of that wave and had some more super fights when he was more capable of wining the.

 

Hatton makes Katsidis his wife :thumbsup

 

Probably Hatton to wear him down and stop him in 8 rounds.