Whats your definition of p4p and who's in your top 10?

147 - He is not proven
140 - He has never fought at the weight
135 - One fight against a human punching bag.

His best weight is 130.

 

im asking now..his ideal weight now..he cannot make it to 130

 

I would favour Caballero to beat Lopez (not too sure what the official betting would be).

But Head-2-Head shouldn't come into the argument in a pound-4-pound argument. If it did then we would be pretty ****ed when it comes to Pavlik-Taylor-Hopkins and Cotto-Mosley-Margarito. Plus Darchinyan would be placed below Donaire, which he clearly is not in most people's P-4-P lists.

Styles make fights.

 

135lb. He has at least shown that he can be really effective at that weight, whereas he has never fought at 140, and his fight against Oscar turned out to be a farce. He has no chance at being competitive with the best of the Welterweights.

 

maybe you favored hatton bec pac is moving outside his comfort zone of 135 lbs...

again to ask, when was the last time a lower ranked p4p is favored to beat a higher ranked p4p fighter